unforum

[chaos]

all i sees is a bit of blurring, which is probably from turning around wit the camera

[TheAtroxious]

Okay, a bit off topic, but...is this for real?

http://victor-surge.deviantart.com/

'Cause if he's really who he pretends to be, I need to start worshiping. If not...damn dirty impostor.

[incedio]

I can't wait for TTA's response.

The way I picture it, he's either going to show the struggle from his point of view, or play with the knife that stabbed him and the SM doll.

His next video can let us know if he's benevolent or dangers as well...

I doubt J would be going back to the house, lol.

[chaos]

1) we don't know EFG is TTA
2) we don't know EFG was stabbed

[BaronVonCakeman]

[Rachiepie]

The following reply was posted on the something awful Marble Hornets threat by Ce Gars, who is known to be J. He is clearly posting it in-game, as he is in character and everything:

[Rachiepie]

^^
Threat=Thread

[Kilo]

Really, I fully expect TTA's response to, at the very least, put a concrete cast on motivations and relationships here.

[Kilo]

[incedio]

[iFaux]

Whoa whoa whoa, EFG DID attack him? Well, now that's something to know..

[Murder101]

Random idea i got while reading pg 139, sorry it its been suggested. The post that said maybe a 3rd person/creature protected J from the masked guy.

What if TTA is hunting slenderman and anyone under his control and is using J as SM bait.

Like J started putting up the vids, TTA saw them and started repling to manipulate J into provoking SM

[Sylvine]

So this shoots down the stab theory as well as the not-hostile theory, also - not completely, though - the third party theory, as J doesn't mention anything about it. There could have still been someone he didn't notice, of course.

It doesn't say much about why the attack took place, though, that's still open to interpretation.

Hm. J picks up doll. Some slight distortion happens. Then he approaches EFG, who suddenly attacks.

I wonder who it was that EFG perceived standing in that hall...or what. The motive remains a point of great interest.

~Sylv

[Rachiepie]

I've been following the SA thread pretty closely (never posted here before though... Hi, all) and I don't recall Ce Gars (J) ever directly answering questions before. He's posted a few times, but never with any sort of a committed answer. This makes me think that perhaps he saw the theories that were developing as a threat to the storyline? Like, he wants us to begin figuring things out and decided to give us some guidance? Who knows.

This definitely all flies in the face of the theories I was buying into, though.

Unless, of course, J remembers incorrectly. But, from a storytelling perspective, I doubt he'd intervene to deliberately mislead us... we're all doing a good enough job of not figuring anything out on our own!

[kylok]