Return to Unfiction unforum
 a.r.g.b.b 
FAQ FAQ   Search Search 
 
Welcome!
New users, PLEASE read these forum guidelines. New posters, SEARCH before posting and read these rules before posting your killer new campaign. New players may also wish to peruse the ARG Player Tutorial.

All users must abide by the Terms of Service.
Website Restoration Project
This archiving project is a collaboration between Unfiction and Sean Stacey (SpaceBass), Brian Enigma (BrianEnigma), and Laura E. Hall (lehall) with
the Center for Immersive Arts.
Announcements
This is a static snapshot of the
Unfiction forums, as of
July 23, 2017.
This site is intended as an archive to chronicle the history of Alternate Reality Games.
 
The time now is Fri Nov 15, 2024 6:44 am
All times are UTC - 4 (DST in action)
View posts in this forum since last visit
View unanswered posts in this forum
Calendar
 Forum index » Chaotic Fiction » Marble Hornets
[Video] Entry 32
Moderators: Giskard, JKatkina, Zarggg
View previous topicView next topic
Page 20 of 24 [347 Posts]   Goto page: Previous 1, 2, 3, ..., 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24  Next
Author Message
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

Here are some thoughts that I want to address as I catch up through the last 11 pages. XD I'll try to arrange them by subject so that it's not such a random slog; sorry for wall of text but with you guys posting so often and me being stubborn and wanting to read it all, I just want to talk to EVERYONE. (8B)

And I'm about to, like, quadruple-post. I figured it'd be less insanely annoying to read several posts that were each a subject unto themselves, than one HUGE post that would take days to slog through. Feel free to skim or skip; I know some'a you have expressed that you do so anyways! Very Happy


Regarding TTA, Masky, and Related Speculation
-The last TTA video was from 11 months ago; In character, Jay followed the 'Stay Home, Be Alone' instructions from Warning to a T for several weeks, before he fled his apartment and it was burned down. The latest TTA video has no bearing on the current situation; If anything, Entry ###### has more bearing and is more recent than Warning.

chaos wrote:
and her going maskey is a definite, pretty foreshadowed possibility, all i meant was, it wouldn't fit the narrative as we've seen it so far for jess to go masky this soon


I fail to see how Jessica becoming a masked character is foreshadowed, let alone a definite possibility. Just because she has bags under her eyes and a moment of 'masky like appearance' during a flicker of distortion does not give me grounds to believe that this is the inevitable outcome. It's just as (and in my mind, more) likely that she is a victim of memory loss and the Operator, and has been investigating Jay in her own way to determine whether or not he's the cause of all of her troubles.

Hell, we have more anecdotal evidence that Jay is going to "go Masky" on Jessica. There are points in the earlier entries that he mentions he doesn't remember being around for. Alex mentions that he's 'gone' in #22; there's a possibility that Jay is not trusted by Alex, if 'Exit' was taped by Alex and fell into TTA's hands after the fact, rather than being a video taped by TTA while it happened. Using the leapfrogging-to-conclusions method, the latest Masky pictures that we see sport a dark brown hoodie much akin to the one that Jay's wearing, and posts to his Twitter account, which he says he didn't post, but for which he has no alibi.

-So TTA hasn't shown up for nearly a year, now. There's been Entry ###### and those twitter pics, but it does feel as though the creators are phasing him out of the story. I worry, being a fangirl, myself (shaaaaaame but true!) that they got bored of him, or just didn't like the fans that had accreted around the character. However, I'm thinking that since TTA has gained such a cult following, his value as a character in our minds has skyrocketed, even compared to the Operator. It doesn't take much to see that: the inordinate amount of time spent speculating over multi-maskies, Timmasky(?!), Skully's gender, identity, and mask sophistication (in pretty much that order of importance) shows that we have got our minds on the character. That gives him an insane amount of cachet in the series, and means that the creators can leave him absent for months (and flippin' years) at a time, and we don't forget about him; we still question his motives even though he hasn't been around.

I think that what's more likely, rather than the creators just getting bored, is that they're cashing in on TTA's popularity by generating more mystery in absentia. It's probable that he'll turn up somewhere further down the road when the story lines finally get tied together, if they decide to make a story that actually resolve some of its fundamental questions somewhere down the line. Or maybe this is just me sheltering a tiny candle of hope for "MOAR TTA U GUIZ" or something. Anyways, I like the idea that you guys put forth that TTA will prod Jay with a video of the open safe at some point. I feel that the creators made a definite move, no longer using TTA's account, though... they probably won't go back on that by posting something that's so arbitrarily important. More likely TTA will infringe on Jay's personal space as he has been in his last posts, rather than retreat back to his own account.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 1:58 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

Regarding the Operator
-Also "Operator" is the name of the tall dark and scary character in Marble Hornets. In this case it is the official name, and is distinct and probably copyrighted, different from the "Slender Man" that we see in other stories. People here referring to this character as "Slender Man" or "Slendy" are using a nickname. Sort of like people using "Masky" instead of "Totheark". While "Slender Man" is valid, to a point, it's not what the characters official name is, or at least it's not what the creators call him, so it is slightly less valid than if you were to use "Operator". (It's taking me a while to make the switch, but I'm trying -- if the creators go to the effort to differentiate the character, following their lead on that seems like the least we could do.)

-While the Operator seems only to have been focused on Alex throughout the tapes, we do see anecdotal evidence that other characters are attacked or made to disappear somehow -- Entry #22 confirms this, though the blood that we see at times suggests this as well. It's possible and likely that if both Jessica and Jay have experienced symptoms of his presence, he is willing and able to chase them both down without regard for focusing on one or the other, especially if they are both in one place at a time. It will be interesting to see who takes precedence: I'm guessing Jessica, as Jay always seems to have been an accomplice to stalkees, what with hanging around Alex, and Jessica expressing her fear of dreams and being watched. It could be that the Operator doesn't so much watch one person at a time as that this is only what we can perceive; Alex having a camera messed with his ability to perform his usual tasks. Jay may be causing a similar problem if he is near to Jessica, and the mere presence of his cameras could be pissing the Operator off!

ultrassjstuart wrote:
Do you somehow think he'll escape Slendy for good?
Or perhaps think just him and his camera will find a way to destroy the superpowerful interdimensional being stalking him once and for all?


May I ask an off topic question? Are you from the states? I'm only asking because it seems like a lot of people from the states prefer stories that end with, "and then they destroyed it once and for all!"

In response to your question, I don't think that this can end well, but I have hope that this can end in a stalemate or a truce... for now. There's obviously hope that one can lead a normal life for a good portion of time, if #26 showed Alex in a new house with a girlfriend who knew nothing about his filming past. Regardless of whether that's a tenuous, fragile goal to aim for, it's something eminently more hopeful than an ending where everyone dies. I don't think that we can foresee the ending and lay down our hope just yet. Stories are made to question our faith in the protagonist and his or her current situation. While they could die, there's still a chance that they won't. There's even still a chance that life won't be hell for the rest of what they have left. A lot of people have already stated a nearly identical point of view, so this is a little redundant, but I think that there are some twists and turns yet to come. This question may just be a little premature, is all!

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 1:59 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

Regarding the Current Situation
-I don't want to fall in with the camp of shippers and people who are desperately filling in the gaping hole of 'what happened in the last seven months?!' with stories of Jay and Jessica's supposed fling and fallout. I think it would be more important and relevant to examine the seperate but adjoining rooms as having one of a couple of different reasons.

1) Jay and Jessica were working together previously, but both are private people (you see how much Jay interacts with us these days, in addition to how Jessica interacts with him awkwardly and keeps her doors always mostly shut) and so decided that adjoining rooms were best.
-In this case, I foresee PoisonMolasses' prediction of picking up the lost memory puzzle pieces as being the next move for our entries. They could each be in possession of parts of memories that the other lacks and begin to build a more solid understanding of what happened, and what events led to their current situation.

2) Jay and Jessica's lives intersected more recently, so adjoining rooms were called for because they weren't certain of one another, or if they could trust one another.
-In this case, it seems like a pretty big coincidence that Jessica is being stalked, and that her life has happened to intersect with Jay's. I feel that there has to be a reason at some point that Jessica got involved, and I think that saying that she's related (as a friend, a sister, a significant other, etc.) to one of the MH crew could be a cop-out. It could be that, what with Alex sounding more calm in #26, and Jay's decision to embroil himself once again in aggressively investigating, he could have started trying to track dow the Operator, and came across Jessica along the way. If she says that she's had dreams of being a child and being stalked by him, she could simply be a victim in orbit of the Operator's world, or realm, or series of unfortunate events, just like the MH crew. It could be that they just intersected at some point.

3) Jay and Jessica were planted at the hotel next to one another without previous knowledge of one another (Jessica feeling that Jay's name was familiar could be a point against this, but with the amnesia it is really hard to say conclusively one way or another!) and so were given adjoining rooms, the better to stumble on one another and ask questions.
-I put this thought forward because the new entries began with Masky tweets, and TTA entries had almost always been created with the aim to force Jay to open up, to question and investigate, and to move things along. With those two thoughts in mind, I think that it could be relevant that they were planted and made to 'wake up' so that they could discover one another and work on figuring out what happened.

poisonmolasses wrote:
Just had a thought.

True, J and Jessica may have met up and been "on the run" together (or something akin to it) in the past seven months and simply fallen into amnesia. However, one thing has kept bugging me about this theory - why would they (A) pay twice as much to stay in two rooms and (B) in doing so effectively eliminate the oft-perceived advantage of safety in numbers?

And while I can see the gender barrier possibly being a factor, jesus h christ people this isn't 1960. If they were dealing with something as horrifying as the Operator you'd think they'd try to conserve resources.

At any rate, if this has been brought up before I apologise. Carry on.


This is a legitimate question, and one that I don't think is going to wind up being solved by 'oh, they're ex's now.' Like JKatkina said, I don't think that MH is that kind of story. (Go to the Resident Evil movies if you want that sort of amnesia plot, guys.)

Given especially that Jay demands Jessica leave her door open, I see your point. I think that it lends credence to my third point, even though I'm not too fond of it. (Again, that could just be me wanting to see TTA involve some how, rather than going off of evidence!)

-Regarding upcoming entries, I think that at this point, they are probably going to skip the fright factor, and that we'll probably get something after the fact. They've used the scare-and-run in #26 to great effect... though I think that we have built up a hype in our minds. "What are Jay and Jessica doing right now!? Are they dead?! It's been three days! Are they alright?!" Can they film something that adequately matches, in our minds, the horror that the characters are going through? They can try... but I think that with the current wait, it's more likely that they're going to let us do that work for them, and then move on with the story that they're laying out. Not to say that it will be boring and un-scary, but it seems as though they're going to play off of the tactic that the unseen is more scary. Whether or not Jay and Jessica are okay but on the run, or hurt and unable to communicate with the rest of us, I think that the creators have things under control and aren't going to pull a sucker-punch like, "Jay's dead, Jess will take over uploading entries." For one, it's been done, for another, it's cheesy as hell in the context of this series.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 1:59 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

Off Topic But Awesome
TheBioGuy wrote:
Do you have any proof of this? Does anyone in this forum that keeps saying they know how masky works have ANY proof?

People like you keep ruining what, to me, is the best part of this series. It refuses to define things. It leaves you wondering.

We don't know if masky is good or evil, insane and mysterious or sane and acting the part, the Operator's slave or his enemy, for or against Jay... Masky is so undefined. We've never (to my knowledge) seen one that isn't the one that is seemingly Tim, with the possible exception of the October twitpic.

And yet that's the one part of masky that people here keep claiming we DON'T know. They say we have no idea who masky is or how many there are when it seems reasonably cut-and-dried that there is probably one, and he is most likely Tim.

TL;DR, stop trying to pretend we know anything about masky. We clearly don't. And stop using him as a stop-gap in your theories.


Quoting this belatedly because it is awesome! People have glamorized TTA, filled in the missing pieces so that they can literally adore him and then make huge leaps to conclusions as far off base as time travel and Masky underground Slenderman-tracking societies. :\ It's creepy. Go back to reading Twilight and GTFO of my fandom.

poisonmolasses wrote:
What I'm seeing, which may or may not be me drunkenly reading into things, is a storyline which is about to become retrograde. The (early) big face-off with the Operator, and the great reveal as to who ToTheArk really is, as well as the herstory of Jessica have all happened within the last few months, with all the traumatic bits removed piece by piece from the current main characters' memories. And the next few months will see those memories slowly replaced, in true southern style, with no effect on the experiencer's psyche but a great deal of rigmarole. Videotape to follow?


Quoted because this was hilarious and probably more on par with what is actually going to happen than what a lot of people have been speculating while sober. You need to post more often, sir or ma'am!


thebioguy wrote:
At first I was curious as to why people thought there was more than one masky, then as I saw the lack of evidence, I just got frustrated. And on top of that I'm grumpy. So I'm sorry that I was being mean to you. But checking to see if your theory has been speculated before isn't that hard. I've learned to.


Welcome to being a forum regular. ;P This may sound depressing, but the more often you visit and post, the more frustrating it gets to see the same shit piled up (often in the same thread!!) from people who think that they've just solved everything and are the first to do so. I think this is why a lot of older members being to stop posting; the turnover gets kind of stupid, literally. On the plus side, for those who stick around -- and for the newbies who take the time to read, think, compose their thoughts and post them in a way that shows that they've used their brains, it becomes pretty satisfying to hold a conversation with others who are on the same page as you! If only I had the ability to ignore certain posts so that I don't have to read through all of the tripe.....



AND I'M DONE! If you read all of this, you hereby are granted all of my internets! *dumps trucks full of golden stars on those rare few who stuck it out!*

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:00 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
Akemi-Idane
Boot


Joined: 22 Dec 2010
Posts: 65

JKatkina wrote:
If there was more than one person prancing around in a mask, we would have had way, way more evidence of it by now. The closest we've ever got is the tenuous connection of the Masky's hoodie from the twitpic being similar to the hoodie we see Jay wearing (and that's assuming, like, Tim didn't change his damn clothes at least once in the intervening months). IF there is another Masky, if it's anyone, it's probably Jay. Which is the only theory that makes logical sense and actually has some support when it comes to multiple Maskies, and even then it's still on pretty shaky ground.

I would like to mention that a song completely appropriate to the 'Jay is a Masky' theory started playing when I read this. Means nothing (except that my pandora can read my mind), but funny tidbit. xD

I personally subscribe to the 'Jay is becoming a Masky' theory myself, and I also don't really like the idea of Skully. I mean yes, there was something that was mask-like in some distortion in Entry 26, but...so what? It hasn't DONE anything. And especially since the Maskies tend to be the active ones, I find that very suspicious.
My main proof for Jay becoming a Masky before had to do with him having the same symptoms as Tim - because Alex was never coughing, or taking strange pills. At least not that we saw - and I don't think that that's something Jay would keep from us. The only people coughing were Jay and Tim. But then Jessica showed up, and she's coughing as well, so I don't think that can be sited as proof anymore and now Alex's just special.
Then we have the distortion on him in Entry 32, and I squee'd. Since it visually distorts over Jessica when she says stuff that's Slender-relevant, of course, but it's fuzzing out on Jay all the time. Similar to how it fuzzed over on Tim. <3
Also, we assume that the blood in Entry 29 belongs to whoever Jay was Masky-stalking at the time (since he and Slenderman, although not necessarily in cohoots, don't seem opposed - he doesn't run when Slendy shows up at the end of tunnel, and his appearance might have triggered something in Jay), but that's really stuff we (we being my friends and I) assume that doesn't have any solid proof to it yet.
I'm not sure.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:01 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

Akemi-Idane wrote:
JKatkina wrote:
If there was more than one person prancing around in a mask, we would have had way, way more evidence of it by now. The closest we've ever got is the tenuous connection of the Masky's hoodie from the twitpic being similar to the hoodie we see Jay wearing (and that's assuming, like, Tim didn't change his damn clothes at least once in the intervening months). IF there is another Masky, if it's anyone, it's probably Jay. Which is the only theory that makes logical sense and actually has some support when it comes to multiple Maskies, and even then it's still on pretty shaky ground.

I would like to mention that a song completely appropriate to the 'Jay is a Masky' theory started playing when I read this. Means nothing (except that my pandora can read my mind), but funny tidbit. xD

I personally subscribe to the 'Jay is becoming a Masky' theory myself, and I also don't really like the idea of Skully. I mean yes, there was something that was mask-like in some distortion in Entry 26, but...so what? It hasn't DONE anything. And especially since the Maskies tend to be the active ones, I find that very suspicious.
My main proof for Jay becoming a Masky before had to do with him having the same symptoms as Tim - because Alex was never coughing, or taking strange pills. At least not that we saw - and I don't think that that's something Jay would keep from us. The only people coughing were Jay and Tim. But then Jessica showed up, and she's coughing as well, so I don't think that can be sited as proof anymore and now Alex's just special.
Then we have the distortion on him in Entry 32, and I squee'd. Since it visually distorts over Jessica when she says stuff that's Slender-relevant, of course, but it's fuzzing out on Jay all the time. Similar to how it fuzzed over on Tim. <3
Also, we assume that the blood in Entry 29 belongs to whoever Jay was Masky-stalking at the time (since he and Slenderman, although not necessarily in cohoots, don't seem opposed - he doesn't run when Slendy shows up at the end of tunnel, and his appearance might have triggered something in Jay), but that's really stuff we (we being my friends and I) assume that doesn't have any solid proof to it yet.
I'm not sure.


What makes you assume that 'becoming a Masky' is a universal trait of being stalked by the Operator? In as far as we have seen, 'being a Masky' could very well have been Tim's individual defense against the symptoms that he was feeling, or a direct reaction to the slew of mental side-effects of hysteria, paranoia, general fear, and insomnia that it seems people suffer. There isn't really anything to directly suggest that others have mimicked Tim (and I'm assuming that Tim is TTA/Masky because of the burns and the clothes and the pills; Skully doesn't count.)

That's not to say that Jay could have experimented with a mask if he felt that perhaps it had some armor-like property, but I just fail to see how people are leaping to the conclusion that wearing a mask means that one is becoming a Slender-minion. We don't even know if TTA/Masky is under the Operator's assumptive direct control, or if the character is just a batshit stalker with his own agenda!

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:11 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
JKatkinaModerator
Entrenched


Joined: 16 Jan 2010
Posts: 825
Location: Calgary, AB

Dray wrote:
WHAT IS THIS SO MUCH WRITING

HOLY SHIT LADY. That was something epic. My god, but it's going to take a while to digest and respond to that.

Dur...

Dray wrote:
That's not to say that Jay could have experimented with a mask if he felt that perhaps it had some armor-like property, but I just fail to see how people are leaping to the conclusion that wearing a mask means that one is becoming a Slender-minion. We don't even know if TTA/Masky is under the Operator's assumptive direct control, or if the character is just a batshit stalker with his own agenda!


This is so very how I see the Masky mask thing playing out. It's not some mystical object that turns the wearer into some mysterious and crazy otherworldly creature -- it's a defense mechanism, perhaps with some effect against Slender symptoms, and is donned voluntarily by folks who want to keep their (remaining) sanity, not automatically by those who have lost it.

TTA, to be fair, does seem a bit nuts in his videos, but he also seems cogent. He seems like a man with a plan. If the mask is a protective device, frankly that just makes him seem MORE sane. The Operator has never seemed like he has a plan or even motivations that we can comprehend, but TTA needles Jay into various actions, (possibly) abducts him places and brings him home, and has at least once outright stated a goal he has -- to get to "the ark". That suggests to me that they are two different players in the game, but because we can't possibly know what the Operator's motives are, we can't really decisively say either way whether TTA falls more in line with Jay's goals, or whether he's closer to being on the Operator's scary team.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:20 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Dray
Pretty talky there aintcha, Talky?


Joined: 15 Jan 2010
Posts: 2578
Location: Cowtown, AB

One point against TTA being a third party in the game of the Operator vs the MH group: the Operator's name suggests that he has some ability to make connections, or perhaps to operate on people... it could be implied that as the Operator, the Masky character is under his control and is being used to connect with Jay and perhaps others... because the Operator doesn't seem to have a conceivable goal of his own, it could be that TTA is being used to express that purpose for him.

That's just based off of name associations, though, and I don't think that it's a strong point in favor of Slender-minionization. It seems more likely to me that you're right about a character struggling to maintain sanity or put a barrier between himself and a force that otherwise doesn't seem to obey our rules and personal space! I have to wonder if Tim tried tinfoil hats at some point on the journey to discovering the masky mask....

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:36 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
Akemi-Idane
Boot


Joined: 22 Dec 2010
Posts: 65

Dray wrote:
What makes you assume that 'becoming a Masky' is a universal trait of being stalked by the Operator? In as far as we have seen, 'being a Masky' could very well have been Tim's individual defense against the symptoms that he was feeling, or a direct reaction to the slew of mental side-effects of hysteria, paranoia, general fear, and insomnia that it seems people suffer. There isn't really anything to directly suggest that others have mimicked Tim (and I'm assuming that Tim is TTA/Masky because of the burns and the clothes and the pills; Skully doesn't count.)

That's not to say that Jay could have experimented with a mask if he felt that perhaps it had some armor-like property, but I just fail to see how people are leaping to the conclusion that wearing a mask means that one is becoming a Slender-minion. We don't even know if TTA/Masky is under the Operator's assumptive direct control, or if the character is just a batshit stalker with his own agenda!

I don't think it's a universal trait - hence why my theory was hurt when Jessica started coughing as well, because that made it less special.

And Masky is definitely batshit, and I don't think he's a slender-minion, I think he's slender-obsessed. Tim said he wasn't involved much with Alex or the project and was just there by circumstance - but it sounded like he had to search hard in his head for that, and he could very easily be made to forget if he had really been involved (or he could be lying, to keep Jay from trying to talk to him again/suspect him). Keep in mind I'm going that Tim is Masky here - I know that some people still insist that that might not be the case.
What I think is that Masky is kind of a slender-fanboy - you know those types of people that kind of idolize serial killers while actually being otherwise normal because they want to examine them or whatever other reason? (I do, I am one.) I think that Tim/Masky was one of those people, and is more the kind to actively pursue Slenderman. But, Slendy isn't paying attention to Masky - he's paying attention to Alex. Now Masky's been slowly going more insane because of the constant slender-presence (amnesia can really screw people up, depending on how badly they want to remember, and Masky would really want to remember any slender-encounters he had) that he's forcing himself into, and he's slowly getting more and more unable to deal with the fact that he's essentially being ignored. So he decides that if he can't get Slendy with himself, then he'll find someone else relatively in the loop (Jay) and attract Slendy to this one. Slenderman only half-bites - he kind of appeases Masky a little, but his focus still isn't on Jay. His focus is still on Alex. This explains why Jay hasn't really seen much of the slenderman firsthand - it's mostly been through tapes of slenderman stalking Alex.
So Masky starts trying harder. He lures Jay back to the house again and again, knowing that it's a slender-presence hotspot, and eventually, Jay finds him. In the most basic terms, Slenderman has now taken the bait, because Jay's caught him on film. Hence Entry 24 - Jay's house is becoming dimension-warping because now Slenderman CARES.
So he does technically have his own agenda - it is just a Slender-agenda. While Jay is trying to run from Slenderman, Masky is trying to get closer.
I like the idea that Masky hasn't posted anything because he's got to go get to Jay - Slenderman's interested enough in Jay now, likely because he already has Alex (I've got something else considering the aftermath of ep.26), and wants to be able to study him without this little twit with the mask getting in the way. So he separates them. Jay doesn't know where he is, and Masky's likely had to figure it out. But when he does - he needs his bait back. Hence the "go home, be alone" - it's much easier to use the bait when the bait will stay put.

But anyway, Jay being Masky.
We never knew much about those pills first season, did we? I mean people have been suspecting that they're seizure pills (which I actually think is really neat but kills this), but they could be 'roofies', of sorts - and you'd be surprised how much people will respond to simple directions while they're in a very deep sleep. (Also, Entry 19, he could have just turned off the dang camera. I mean he was RIGHT. THERE.)
Or, and this is closer to actually making sense - Jay's slowly going crazy himself from slender-presence (which has increased substantially thanks to Masky) and just from the general feeling of being stalked, and his subconscious could see this scary, otherwordly force, and could see this other person who's seemingly invincible to this otherwordly force with a face covering, and go "Huh, that seems like a good idea".
And then Jay, once he donned the mask as a form of protection, realizes there's a new victim since he's harder to touch now. So he starts behaving like the 'masky' for this victim - trying to scare him off. I don't think Masky is benevolent - but Jay is. And it would make much more sense to try to approach him normally, but in all honesty, who's going to trust the guy in the mask who's got a camera strapped to his chest and is talking like a crazy person? Because Jay's gotta keep the mask on - it's his defense.
Entry 29 was the aftermath of that - Jay failed. He either just didn't do anything to make it better, or he actually made it worse, and the person is dead now. Hence why he seems rather horrified by the bloody rag - he realizes what he's done.
It's entirely possible that at this point he's flipped up the mask out of respect or a more practical reason (like he's crying or something. It could be), and Slendy appears at the end of the tunnel to find an uncovered Jay. Bam, caught him again. Jay's made to forget what can defeat the slenderman, and dropped in across from another victim - possibly to see him fail again, Slenderman likes to play with his food.
What's in the safe is his mask.

There's not a lot of real evidence for any of this, and it is kind of like a "wouldn't it be neat if...", but considering that we know almost nothing about Masky...it could be.
Tear this apart as you will.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:46 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
theonewhoquestions
Unfettered


Joined: 11 Mar 2010
Posts: 377

Dray wrote:
Alex mentions that he's 'gone' in #22; there's a possibility that Jay is not trusted by Alex, if 'Exit' was taped by Alex and fell into TTA's hands after the fact, rather than being a video taped by TTA while it happened. Using the leapfrogging-to-conclusions method, the latest Masky pictures that we see sport a dark brown hoodie much akin to the one that Jay's wearing, and posts to his Twitter account, which he says he didn't post, but for which he has no alibi.


I think the idea that Alex doesn't trust Jay to be an interesting one.
I have so many thoughts about this though, that I don't want to really bring them up till I have it all straight in my head. Which is why I erased the bulk of this post.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 2:53 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
JKatkinaModerator
Entrenched


Joined: 16 Jan 2010
Posts: 825
Location: Calgary, AB

Akemi-Idane wrote:
There's not a lot of real evidence for any of this, and it is kind of like a "wouldn't it be neat if...", but considering that we know almost nothing about Masky...it could be.
Tear this apart as you will.


No, you know what... this is a reasonably solid, complete theory. It may not be perfect but first read-through doesn't present anything really glaring. :3 It's not my favorite theory -- like everyone else I've got my own pet TTA theory -- but it's not bad!

I especially like the idea of Jay being someone else's masky when stated like this. It'd just be too good if he misconstrued TTA's intentions so badly that he ended up playing a benevolent Masky to another Slender-victim. Now, I don't think that's the way the story will go, but I wouldn't be heartbroken if it did.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 3:31 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
distilled
Unfettered


Joined: 18 Mar 2010
Posts: 732
Location: Midlands, UK

I have to admit, I've never liked the idea of SM/Operator taking people on as slaves or apprentices - I like to think that Masky/TTA has his own intentions (however messed up they may be).

I also hope that Jay has not been his own Masky for the past 7 months, I don't know why - but I just don't feel right with that theory. Forgive me for saying "Do not want!" without coming up with a viable counter theory, its just how I feel atm!
_________________
http://verydistilled.blogspot.com
Passionate about an ARG? Click here to sign up to be a guest writer on my blog, tell us why!


PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 3:35 pm
 View user's profile Visit poster's website
 Back to top 
Akemi-Idane
Boot


Joined: 22 Dec 2010
Posts: 65

JKatkina wrote:
No, you know what... this is a reasonably solid, complete theory. It may not be perfect but first read-through doesn't present anything really glaring. :3 It's not my favorite theory -- like everyone else I've got my own pet TTA theory -- but it's not bad!

I especially like the idea of Jay being someone else's masky when stated like this. It'd just be too good if he misconstrued TTA's intentions so badly that he ended up playing a benevolent Masky to another Slender-victim. Now, I don't think that's the way the story will go, but I wouldn't be heartbroken if it did.

Thanks! Smile
We (being my friends and I) are kind of working through it and editing it as the story goes along, and of course there are crux-points (like, if the blood in Entry 29 ends up belonging to the other Masky, my Jay becoming a masky is kind of screwed) that haven't been officially revealed yet, but I like it.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 3:39 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
JKatkinaModerator
Entrenched


Joined: 16 Jan 2010
Posts: 825
Location: Calgary, AB

distilled wrote:
I have to admit, I've never liked the idea of SM/Operator taking people on as slaves or apprentices - I like to think that Masky/TTA has his own intentions (however messed up they may be).

I also hope that Jay has not been his own Masky for the past 7 months, I don't know why - but I just don't feel right with that theory. Forgive me for saying "Do not want!" without coming up with a viable counter theory, its just how I feel atm!


You know what dude, I am almost totally with you. This is the first time ever that I've liked a theory where J dons the mask, mostly because it'd be so in-character for him to so grossly misinterpret TTA's intentions!

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 3:44 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Bingo Zero
Boot


Joined: 12 Dec 2010
Posts: 54

I like the idea that Masky is a slender-fanboy, that he's Tim and he becomes obsessed with the Operator. I don't think that the mask has any special powers, but as a mental defense Tim creates this second personality as totheark and wears a mask to become TTA. In his mind Tim is vulnerable to the slenderification but TTA is invulnerable, so he needs to be the invulnerable TTA. But TTA isn't invulnerable, it's just Tim in a mask, as we've see TTA have a seizure and when Jay goes to remove the mask Tim freaks out, he needs to be TTA.

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2011 4:09 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Display posts from previous:   Sort by:   
Page 20 of 24 [347 Posts]   Goto page: Previous 1, 2, 3, ..., 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24  Next
View previous topicView next topic
 Forum index » Chaotic Fiction » Marble Hornets
Jump to:  

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
You cannot post calendar events in this forum



Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group