unforum

Undertheark · Veteran Joined: 27 Nov 2010 Posts: 140

For some reason I like and don't like, it seems like its becoming more focused on death and killing rather than Slenderman and being helpless. Personally I mostly liked it.
A rock to the face leaves people damaged beyond any extent almost certainly breaking a nose maybe killing. I'm going for in a critical state of no return.
Also, why was Alex there and how did he know about Masky; we figured that Slendy was an Alex only occurance and Masky Jay only.

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:14 am

Takub · Boot Joined: 15 Feb 2011 Posts: 10 Location: :noitacoL

If Alex did cut a deal to get out of this mess (as theorised earlier), that might explain why he was so aggressive towards Masky - besides the knife attack - he thought he was out and here (perhaps) comes Masky dragging him back in.
I don't personally think this is what happened but hey it's possible
$0.02

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:17 am

TheCrimsonKnight

Finally got to seeing this. I�m speechless.

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:28 am

Sofos · Boot Joined: 10 Jul 2007 Posts: 17

Is anyone else realizing that we are missing HUGE chunks of time in these videos?

Okay, firstly, I'm posing this under the presumption that Alex had traveled to the house with Jay, and was simply looking around outside until he came in the door. When Jay talks, he's not talking to the camera (the only talking he's ever done besides simply calling out "Hello" or something like that is directly to the camera, when he gives up, and while driving at the beginning of #34. But here, he talks out loud, as if someone is there. The walls are thin, I imagine he would have expected Alex to hear him. Alex brought him there, obviously expecting to find something. He was compelled.

In any case, I'm pretty sure that Alex and Jay had met up prior to this entry. For how long, I don't know, but it's pretty clear that there are important chunks missing from the footage we've been shown. This brings up the question: where is all the missing footage? Should we assume Masky has it? Or that TTA has it?

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:34 am

blue5213 · Boot Joined: 02 Nov 2009 Posts: 68

Holy shit holy shit holy shit shit just got REAL

Don't know why there's any discussion about Jay and Alex meeting "off-camera" or anything. It's quite obvious that A) Alex is a little surprised to see Jay there, B) Jay is shocked to see Alex, C) Alex puts his finger to his mouth in a "be quiet" motion before pointing past Jay, indicating Masky is there. There's no reason to believe that this isn't the first time they've seen each other since Alex gave Jay the original tapes. This is clearly meant to show Jay finding Alex again and, well, not exactly liking what he sees.

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:54 am

RoundWounds · Kilroy Joined: 16 Feb 2011 Posts: 1

Hey guys,

Long time lurker, first time poster. Just wanted to point out (I'm sure it already has) that the knife already had blood on it when the camera focused on it.

Edit: Also, a number of you seem to be stuck on the fact that Tim is still alive JUST because we've seen masky recently. Anyone could've taken his place, even Alex (could've snapped after this incident and took on the role of the exact thing he was trying to kill).

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:07 am

Twitch · Greenhorn Joined: 21 Dec 2010 Posts: 9

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:14 am

awakeasaurusrex · Entrenched Joined: 12 Oct 2010 Posts: 1099

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:24 am

Wolfloner · Veteran Joined: 25 Jan 2011 Posts: 96 Location: Oklahoma

Wow, just spent my morning reading through this thread.

And no one mentioned something that kind of bothered me. I'm sure it's just a little thing, but it feels odd to me.

At the start of the video, J lifts up that board on the floor, for no apparent reason. I know it's probably just "looking around the house" stuff, but in a production like this (low budget, very short entries, ect), I have a hard time thinking that anything we're shown happened for no reason.

Also, I loved this entry. yay. Smile

I had a nice jump-scare with Tim showing up. ^^;

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:27 am

KatoK · Boot Joined: 16 Feb 2011 Posts: 16

Finally managed to join, 'sup? Tried a few months ago, unfiction was being screwy. Lurking since roughly April, first time posting.

"You are broken."
"You can not be fixed."
I think this is a clear reference to his leg Laughing

I'm gonna hop on the bandwagon saying Alex broke his leg, when you can't walk properly, you normally try to avoid walking as much as possible. It isn't easy to exercise with a broken knee, especially when you're running around doing the work of an eldritch abomination for a living. I think putting on a few pounds after being out of commission is reasonable.

Someone else mentioned the lack of Brian- That really irks me. I personally believe TiMasky and Brian are TTA. Now not so sure. Anyone have any ideas why Tim was just grunting? I'm starting to think that he's a mindless proxy now. But, then, how exactly could he put together a video afterwards? Razz

Sorry- I'm ranting all my thoughts out about this entire thread here. The Operator WAS around in Entry 19, I think it's reasonable to say the distortion is caused by an off-screen Operator.

Criticisms?

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:28 am

theonewhoquestions · Unfettered Joined: 11 Mar 2010 Posts: 377

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:31 am

NoMoreGaems · Unfettered Joined: 17 Sep 2010 Posts: 627

Wow, fast thread.

I'm gonna have to agree with the "They just now met" theory, Jay is clearly surprised to see Alex and vice versa. These theories that they met before that are clearly grasping at straws. Now, here's something I know hasn't been pointed out, because unlike other people I actually read the thread:

The last time we saw Alex on camera, the Operator appeared a few seconds later. And now, we see Alex on camera again, and he doesn't seem to thrilled about that, and is definitely in a rush afterwards. And then we start getting distortion and visual tearing...

My theory of 35: Jay's been recording over tapes of himself driving if nothing interesting happens on said tapes, because who needs four hours of driving footage when there's exploration to be had? So he goes back to the shack from 34 and wanders about, angrily cursing the mysterious sender of #26 and wondering if he'll ever get any answers. Meanwhile, Mr. Kralie just happened to be outside because he was waiting or he had followed Tim there, and pops in to surprise his former BFF.
"Jay?"
Jay spins around, and is clearly about to go "Wha-- Alex?! What are you doing here! What's going on!?" or something, when Alex shushes him and points to the source of a noise that came from behind Jay. Jay turns around slowly and leans through the door to reveal the masked man!
A tussle ensues. Tim stabs Alex in the arm, but Alex and Jay manage to disarm him and throw him to the floor. Alex asks Jay's help subduing him and, in a fit of rage, is ready to kill him. Jay refuses and Alex tries to justify his actions with "He's not gonna follow us" while picking up a rock. Jay rushes to stop him, and Tim manages to bring his leg up to keep Alex from smashing his face in. The Operator shows up suddenly, heralded by audio distortion and visual tearing, and Alex drops the rock to escape, smashing Tim's kneecap in the process. The camera dies, and thus the footage on the tape goes back to Jay driving.
Possibly, Alex and Jay are still together in the past, and the next video might show evidence of that, but I doubt it will show Alex himself because he's a Slendermagnet now, just being on camera is enough to summon the Operator.

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:36 am

Mariolee · Unfettered Joined: 14 Feb 2011 Posts: 500

The fact of the matter is we saw Tim in Entry 33. With a limp. We got screencaps of his sideburns, and he looks to be the exact same build. Occam's razor would say Tim survived the rock with a broken knee, and has come back.

Also, to people saying that Tim's face was hit by the rock and is heavily disfigured, I say this. A guy throws a giant heavy ass rock with all his might at someone's vulnerable face. Do you think he survives long enough to belch out a scream?

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:41 am

Jaytenthousand · Boot Joined: 06 Dec 2010 Posts: 43 Location: Canada

Just watched the entry. Decided I didn't want to read all 23 pages, so I just read the first 4 to get the initial theories.

I don't think Tim just brushed by Jay to get to Alex, I think Tim realized that there were two people there, and the likelihood of beating up two people at once is very slim. Fighting isn't like a movie, where you can fight a guy while his friend waits around patiently for a one on one. I'd cut my losses and try and get them alone, if I was a mysterious malicious masked menace.

As for the bloody knife, I suspect it was jay that got cut by Masky. It's hard to see, since the blade is facing the camera, but judging by that, and the manner that Tim was holding his fist when he came out of the room, he was holding the knife at exactly 1:09. I suspect he cut Jay as he was passing by, but was stopped by Alex, and was overpowered during the off camera scuffle.

Also, I didn't really notice any limp in #33, after re-watching it.

**Posted:** Wed Feb 16, 2011 10:44 am