unforum

[Mariolee]

[KeithXK]

Don't have time to read the 22 pages at the moment.

But here it is, in my view.

I noticed in 33 that Masky had a different build from before. Definitely different hair, different build.

I'm not saying that Alex killed Tim or that Tim is dead at all.

But Tim ISN'T Masky anymore. He was, now he isn't.

I now believe that Masky is an emissary of Slendy, and Tim is no longer suitable, so the mantle was passed to someone else. Think of Galactus and his heralds.

[Mariolee]

[MistrPibb]

My theory is that "he's not going to follow us" refers to Tim demanding to be "lead to the ark".

I'm also 99 percent sure that Tim was injured, but recovered.
A new ToTheArk wouldn't take Tim's jacket.

That's just plain creepy.

[Ikekudeyg]

[StSamovar]

Does anyone else feel like Masky just doesn't really care about Jay? It looks to me as though he's just trying to get out, like he's afraid of Alex.

[dfw]

jeeze guys, way to make a bazillion pages while I was asleep XD
(and btw sleeping was not easy after this entry)

[Sofos]

Regarding Masky in #33, there is evidence both for and against it being Tim. Comparing the Tim and 33's Masky, they are definitely different jackets. They are the same color (upon close comparison, they don't seem identical, but that may be lighting), but Tim is definitely wearing a zip-up hoodie. You can tell it has a zipper when he comes out of the stairwell (which I didn't realize was there, Tim didn't go down there in 34) because it isn't zipped up all the way. You can see it clearly. Masky is wearing a hoodless buttoned jacket in 33. Even so, I could swear Masky has had a couple jackets throughout the series, all in that same sort of yellow-ish color.

Also, if Masky in 33 is indeed another character, his build matches the Park Guy from 31 just enough to be worth considering, I think.

[gonz0]

HOLY CRAP AWESOME VIDEO!!!!!

[TheCrimsonKnight]

After this Entry, this immediately comes to mind: http://jtroyw.blogspot.com/2011/01/surprises.html

[shoeler]

[Leśniak]

Gone over it again. My best guess is that this is actually within only a few days of Entry #26 being posted. Think about it.

J's come back in the morning. He probably left, drove to the nearest hotel, slept it off, then came back to see if he could find anything. He was obviously frustrated (he's realised TTA probably lead him here deliberately), and he reckons he's being taunted, so he calls out in case TTA/whoever is there, watching him.

Turns out Tim is there, probably waiting to jumpscare J for whatever reason, but then when Alex shows up, he gets scared and decided to bolt, so he runs past J, who drops the camera from shock and being shoved aside. Alex blocks him, so Tim goes at him with the knife (hence Alex's "Oh god"). They subdue him. All is well.

There are three possible explanations for Alex showing up:

1. As soon as he'd gotten Amy out of the house in #26, he dodged the Operator (this is the major problem with this theory: What does a brother have to do to pacify the Operator?), but stuck around in the vicinity and waited for whoever to come and retrieve the camera, possibly knowing it would be Tim. He then followed him out to the house in the field and either saw him going in through the side entrance or just worked out that J wasn't a threat because he was ranting about not seeing anything. Pretty pissed off at Tim, he decides that he's going to put him out of action one way or another and breaks his leg with a rock after J points out killing him would be stupid.

2. Alex sent J the tape himself (this seems very unlikely: it's way too antagonistic and it's obviously been doctored what with the "HELP" message at the end) with the return address as a safe meet up point (again unlikely, you'd think he'd have had enough of lurking around abandoned, burnt out buildings by now). Tim could then have been trailing either of them: he seems to have always known their locations throughout all of this.

3. An independent party led Alex, J, and Tim to the same location. This seems most farfetched, because it doesn't explain why Tim immediately hid in the back room, or who planted the camera in Alex's house and sent the tape to J.

[Megarain]

I somewhat doubt it was a fit of rage. Alex's actions....he seems to calm. Like this is what he has to do, because he's done it before. Perhaps its not that easy to kill an agent of the operator.After all, we just saw a masky.

Note: My hand is broken right now, so please excuse any typos.

[dfw]

Does anyone else get the feeling that the green folder is what Masky wanted J to find?
Like J was supposed to find it, and Masky was hiding nearby to make sure he got it and stuff...then Alex was there and Timasky wasn't expecting that.
And that Alex showing up stopped Jay from finding it maybe?
I dunno..random thought. Also, blood on knife..
My theory is Tim felt trapped at knowing 2 people were there, pulled knife out to try and scare them so he could make a run for it. Alex doesn't let him get by and so he gets cut or stabbed as Tim tries to escape, but then he is of course overpowered by the two of them.

[mellodragon]

Wall of text time