unforum

[Aperion]

[distilled]

I think what irritates me about this is that the two people (who I've seen) purporting this theory have both come on and said "Seeing as everyone agrees that there are four Maskys, I think.... blah blah".

I don't know where have found agreement to the 4masky theory, but it sure ain't here! Again, as people have said - this isn't an attack against you, just against the theory really!

I think, and have always thought, that its just the levels of blur/contrast/other filters which makes the masks look ever so slightly different.

[8bitFilk]

I think the third one only looks feminine because the distortion accentuates the lips and eyes in such a way that the face seems more female. There's absolutely nothing outside the mask to indicate gender either way.

Also (and I haven't seen this suggested by anyone yet) I'm not even convinced Skully is a mask in the first place. The head doesn't look like a real head, it looks like a round pillow or a stuffed bag to me, with the skull painted/pasted onto it (though it could be a bag over someone's head). There's not even anything to use as a point of reference for scale, so it may not even be head-sized.

I'm not saying it's not a mask, just saying that we shouldn't assume it is just because it has a face.

[HunterEris]

There is one Masky, not four. We have no proof that the Masky in 33 is Tim, but I still believe it is. Those top three images are distorted, the bottom is the mysterious Skully.

Also, Alex had 5 crew members, not 4. J, Tim, Brian, Sarah, Seth. He appears in the early entry where Alex goes nuts about him not constantly filming.

[Aperion]

[HunterEris]

[TheWorld]

The 4 masky theory comes from Tvtropes.

Personally, I think there's two maskies. Well one masky and skully. I really don't know what to make of skully, but I think we're gonna see a come back seeing as we saw him right before the while thing with Alex and Slendy went down, or maybe it isn't a person at all and just symbolism for something. Maybe it's Jay? Who knows. Too soon to tell. People have been 100% certain on theories will believe it and it turns out to be completely wrong. No harm in guessing though I say.

I usually tend to say nothing at all cause I turn out to be dead wrong.

[bobthecrusher]

I'm pretty sure skully was either a trick of distortion or was just a red herring

[thomasdontask]

I'm just spouting random ideas/theories I've had through this whole deal.
At the end of Entry #35, J obviously looks pissed. Could it be possible, that he's angry that Alex has found out the identity of Tim as Masky?
If (and I understand that some don't agree with the theory) we go along with the "4 masks" theory, could it be possible that J's just angry that one of his fellow masks has been found out?

[distilled]

[Indextic]

[distilled]

[8bitFilk]

[TheBioGuy]

I think this thread has gotten enough attention, now. It's a theory that's been posed before. Someone thought it was original, and that it warranted its own thread (and, like many threads around here, it actually doesn't, move it to the main discussion thread or the discussion on a pertinent video thread).

And the only thing anyone will ever agree upon on "Skully" is that everyone disagrees. I personally agree with 8bit, we have no idea WHAT it is, and we certainly don't have the info to start guessing on "who."

Also, regarding theories that one mask looks more feminine... so what? They are masks. Their point is to obscure the identity of the wearer. Men can wear feminine masks. Heck, I always thought the main mask was kinda feminine. It's in the way the lips are highlighted.

[MsSynclair]