unforum

[Randoman96]

Re: Probably should have killed him

[Young Wayfarer]

I only just joined because I want in on the MH talk but anyways, I've had some of my own theories for a while and I apologize if these have been already gone over I'll try to stay away from those that have.
For my theories, I try to connect all the characters in MH and try to stray away from the typical theories, so stuff like Tim is TTA, Alex is so and so etc.

1) Seth is totheark
I had this small speculation for a while before I looked more closely into Entry 22 (Alex and Seth is some dilapidated basement). Basically E22 showed us that Seth is in on this more than we knew before and more than what we see from the other cast of the Marble Hornets production (Other than Tim). Seth is directly involved in whatever Alex is doing. With this in mind, he has to have some kind of knowledge of the situation if not of Slendy himself.
This accompanied by him being the cameraman and therefore, having direct access and probably has, tapes of his own, he also could have technician/editing skills and therefore could be able to produce the content of TTA's videos.
The flaw here is what happened to Seth in E22. At one point (I cannot recall where, sorry) he 'falls' or something rather and was said to have possibly been dragged away by whatever. I obviously automatically assumed this was Slenderman that dragged him away and I stay by that theory. So seeing as this happened, I want to assume Seth is therefore, dead.
Now there have been no previous cases to Slenderman actually interacting with people other than Alex bleeding in Entry 15 I believe, but even that was unclear.

So now,
2) There are multiple maskies and they are Tim, Brian, Sarah, J and possibly Jessica.
This builds off what I previously said that Seth is dead, if he is not, then he would probably be a masky. I know this is already stated on the wiki somewhere but I felt like emphasizing it again. When watching Entry (Insert however many #'s), I just had a hunch that they weren't showing the same masky over and over again. Another note in this entry is that at one point, the camera films a mask from the inside, as if the VIEWER was wearing a mask, I interpreted this to Jay being the viewer and he is wearing a mask, demonstrating that he is in fact one or will become one. I forget the timeline of E# so I cannot be sure of this.
Now we also go back to E22, Alex says that Seth, Tim, "insert rest of cast of MH" are gone. So Seth is dead, and that leaves the rest of the cast to also having similar fates or he 'lost' them like as we see what happened to Tim, he turned out to be a masky, the others could have followed similar fates.
As for the recent Twitter-Apocalypse scenario that happened just before enttry 37, we are obviously losing Jay, he is slowly drifting off and he is going in a trance. This accompanied with I believe another entry where he is filming himself sleeping and there is a cut in the tape shows that he could of gone off into slender-trance and in this state, he is a masky.

3) Jay posted enttry 37
I state this after seeing Entry #38, where he states he did not.
The only evidence needed to demonstrate that he in fact posted it goes back to the Twitter scenario, the sloppy writing. I don't know how he types when actually in trance but notice how the T is right beside the R on a QWERTY keyboard? Adding an extra T is evident of sloppy typing. Also I do believe totheark posted E#, but that entry had proper capitalization and was done properly, so why would he fuck up writing this one? (inb4 J tried to stop him in trance when TTA was uploading the vid blah blah blah, that's overruled)


Things I'm sure of, in my opinion, is that Tim could not be TTA unless multiple people are TTA WHICH I doubt out of my own unjustified speculation. Tim got messed up by Alex in Entry #35 and yet TTA still posted responses. I just find this extremely unlikely that he still posted, ignoring 35 entirely, UNLESS one of the TTA vids implied some kind of revenge against Alex.

I realize some of the sentence structures in my writing were kind of sloppy, I apologize for that.

[Timur]

theres also the possibility that Alex posted enttry 37, as he delves into insanity...sort of justification for possible actions Alex may do, or to try and say why he feels so impassioned, so desperate. He could have tried to pin it on TTA (or he might be TTA), so Jay wouldn't catch on...because it isn't to him. Its to the world.

[Geneaux486]

[Philosopher Xu]

So we are back on the "fill-in-the-blank-cast-member" is TTA discussions (my favourite). Let's run these down for a sec, these are the possibilities:

Tim - early front-runner, now seems less likely, but still popular

Alex - probably neck and neck with Tim for people's opinion on who TTA is

Seth/ Brian - less likely but have some supporters, do not appear in Season 2

Jessica - This possibility has been mentioned, but she was not in Season 1

The Operator - not likely but can't rule out

Other random person we haven't been introduced to yet, or minor character that appears in only one Entry such as Alex's girlfriend or that actress at the gazebo - also possible

Jay in altered state of consciousness sending messages to himself - throw that in there too.

Or - Combination of more than one of the above

We can't actually rule anything out about this, there's not enough facts to eliminate even the most far-fetched speculations. I will be very happy if anyone can point out anything in the videos that definitively crosses out any of the above as being impossible.