unforum

[bobthecrusher]

so....just a theory here......Alex is TTA, he tells Jay to go the park at night, he shows up with a camera (In case of slendy) and makes sure that Jay isn't going masky on him.

[YamaKami]

[GameGodOfAll]

[Geneaux486]

[mjdolorico]

Something to consider?

[blue5213]

Can't believe nobody brought up the possibility that Tim "acquired" the video that someone else made of Jay sleeping in the car. Doesn't mean they were working together at all. Tim can still be TTA. It just means someone else took that footage and Tim somehow got a hold of it.

After all the shots of Masky and tapes of places where Masky was known to frequent, I don't see how you could make the assumption that Masky =/= TTA. Especially after we got confirmation that Masky = Tim.

[GameGodOfAll]

[Capercorn]

Longtime lurker, first time posting.

You know, we're all assuming that Tim used human medical facilities after his leg smashing...

And if Tim did use human medical facilities, then yes, he wouldn't be walking.

However, if it is the Operator that operates Masky, than would it be far too out there to suggest that perhaps Tim had a visit to the SlenderDoc? That could also explain the limp 7 months later; SlenderDoc just barely fixed the leg.

[bocaj470]

[mjdolorico]

[DHock513]

Well here's what I think: I believe that Skully is another masky/proxy, I believe that ToTheArk is also a proxy, I believe ToTheArk filmed this video, and I believe that Marble Hornets is realistic enough that at least they wouldn't have Tim walking on that broken a leg one week later. So, assuming all those things, I think that ToTheArk isn't Tim, or Regular Masky, which leaves 2 unknown proxies that could be each other. I see no reason to not believe that Skully isn't ToTheArk, and unless there's THREE proxies, I think the simplest explanation is that ToTheArk=Skully. Also, I don't think he's Alex, as in Entry #26 he seems to have actually got away from this whole thing for the past 3.5 years, and also I think Exit was filmed by a 3rd party, but I think (s)he was connected to the original MH movie. Which leaves Seth, Brian, and Sarah as top suspects. Finally, Seth does have some more evidence due to him being the camera man, but before today when I saw this I would've sworn to you ToTheArk was Tim, and I've already speculated quite a lot so I'll leave stuff there.

[aryama5]

Has anyone found what music was being played in the background?
I did a sloppy clean-up of it.

http://cl.ly/0t1a000k2N053q004126 <-- Reversed audio
http://cl.ly/1C2u0i1A2M222r3B190O <-- Original audio

[SlenderSniper]

What the??? I never saw entry 39!!! Damn you youtube for not updating me! Damn you to hell!!! If you'll excuse me I have a video to watch. And BTW... TTA why U so crrraaaaaazy?!?!

[Mariolee]

The only hole I see in the "Alex is TTA" is that it means he must have worked with Tim, and we see in entry 35 that he actually breaks his leg.

Alex is the main guy because aside from Seth, he has all the extra footage of Marble Hornets.
Plus TTA used a bunch of old movies and video editing techniques. Stuff only a film student would be experienced with.
Plus, it's already been slightly confirmed that Alex sent the video in Entry 26, you know, the video with the weird TTA ending?
PLUS, he was the only one shown to have known where Jay was that night.

[Zarggg]

Sadly, I didn't get to see this last night, as my solitary goal then was to complete Portal 2. And I did. At 5 am. But this was a wonderful video to wake up to. I certainly hope that the "something" TTA wants to show Jay is something more substantial, and not just the fact that he likes being a creeper and recording a sleeping Jay. :-\

I said I would accept the figure in Entry #39 being TTA if it turned out to be so, and I will honor that. However, after reading this thread, I have noticed a few things. They may or may not have sufficient backing, so feel free to analyze and comment on them.

Going on face value that TTA was the one taping in 39:
It is less now likely that TTA is Tim, though I still think he's the best candidate based on previous factors/speculation.
It is also possible that TTA is Alex. Despite earlier clues in Season 1 stating the contrary, Alex was the one who told Jay to meet him at the park on the day after this was filmed.
The Operator being TTA seems a bit silly in general -- Why would he communicate with English words printed on a video? -- but is still a possibility.

I have another theory regarding this video. Considering that the events likely took place sometime between last May and October (I like to think that this is near the end of the blackout period, however), and is just being posted now, it is possible that TTA did not film this.

TTA has made a big deal in his videos about Alex being an untrustworthy companion to Jay or at the very least that Alex is absent. I think it is possible that the strange figure in 39 was Alex (back to his paranoid, crazy self now that The Operator is following him again) taping Jay the night before to see whether Jay turns into Masky or not. It is then possible that since the time of this video, something has happened to Alex and TTA was able to obtain his phone, his camera, and other things. Of course, the same evidence that points to this theory also points to Alex=TTA, so take that with a grain of salt.

I realize that there is no direct evidence to support this, but there's no direct evidence against it either. It's a shot-in-the-dark theory about events that we simply have not yet been told enough about. I hope that Entry #40 (or Twitter postings from Jay, even though he doesn't take that avenue often) sheds some more light on this.

Edit: Grammar