unforum

[Lithp]

[Serum]

Maybe ToTheArk is just a troll who plays both sides.

Kind of like Clint Eastwood in "For a Fistful of Dollars," where he just plays both cliques against each other until they destroy each other. And then takes all their money.

[granitemoth88]

It's obvious that Hoody is Brian, for so many reasons. I don't have a screenshot but if you look closely at the scenes where Brian is being dragged off camera in the hospital and where Hoody is in Tim's bedroom, Brian has the same sneakers as Hoody. Brian was really close to Alex, which would explain how Brian has so much inside knowledge and footage. Alex even lived with Brian for a time. There was also a big story arc that took place in Brian's old house, which seemed to be abruptly abandoned. Tim told Jay early on that he should ask Brian if he wanted to know more. Brian is referenced constantly but never seen.

And as for the mask, maybe Brian wears the mask because some specific person or persons think he is dead and he wants to keep it that way? He even wears gloves presumably to cover up fingerprints. I would be totally flabbergasted if Hoody was anyone other than Brian.

[McGregor]

The shoes that Brian and Hoody had are different. This was discussed and debunked when entry 61 came out.

[Wolfman4454]

[prisoner24601]

First, in the latest entry of marble hornets (#67) we clearly see Hoody and Alex together in the same scene, thusly eliminating the theory that Alex = Hoody.

Second, viewers of marble hornets have already deduced that Hoody = ToTheArk through entries made on ToTheArk's youtube channel. This means that ToTheArk cannot be Alex.

So, we have already deduced that ToTheArk cannot be Jay, Alex or Tim as they have all been seen in the same videos as Hoody.

But, of you follow the theory that Hoody is Jay from the future, who has somehow managed to travel back in time to warn the past versions of himself about the impending danger of Alex and the Operator, then ToTheArk could infact be Jay.

P.S. sorry if this has confused anyone.

[Lithp]

It's also ill-advised to use what Jay says he remembers about the events & people surrounding Marble Hornets, because it's already been established that much of it has been cleared from his memory.

[wassupbro]

So first things first.

I don't think totheark is a group of people, but clearly, the owner of the account has changed due to the different types of videos posted now compared to older seasons. The very first totheark video was a response to the very first entry with Tim. Other evidence (the weird "S" thing, the closeups of tim, etc) clearly indicates that Tim was the man behind the account.

At some point, totheark's account was hacked. This might seem a little absurd until one remembers how many times Jay's account was hacked. The difference? Jay can get his account back (with effort). This would explain how Hoody was able to become the new totheark.

Now, who is Hoody? I am almost positive that Hoody is Brian. It would make sense that the two who Alex attempted to "take out" at the abandonded building were in some cultish mask/hood group working against Alex. They're intentions are still unknown, but its safe to say they give Jay many answers.

Why then, would Masky and Hoody NOT share the account? that is my only question if this theory was correct.

I believe its because Tim began to heal. He brought himself back to reality, thus the beginning of season 3. Now Hoody is the only one left, and Tim relies on those drugs to not go back to that life.

[Kraehtot]

[Geneaux486]

totheark is brian and tim, but tim doesn't do it in season 3

[The Condor]

Everyone is totheark. Remember the old lady in the store? She's totheark.

[Geneaux486]

[wassupbro]

[Grumplestiltskin]

[Serum]