unforum

[Ztakk]

[Wubblz]

Despite Entry #45, I'm convinced that Alex is Hoody in the present, and that old footage of Hoody was either "Bruce" under the hood or Hoody was shot off-screen by Alex in 52.

In my defense, this is a "crazy theories" thread.

[Ztakk]

[Wubblz]

It's still more probably than TTA being Sarah or Seth!

[pravado]

If Alex ends up being Hoody I will literally throw up

[Wubblz]

[Zarggg]

[Wubblz]

Alright, here is how I would logically connect Alex to being Hoody in the present:

First, I'm going to go over why Hoody (in Season 3) could be Alex:
-Hoody's Traits In Season 3
Hoody is male, dwells in Rosswood Town, and has a connection to Tim. He has to know about Tim's illness, his medication, his medical history, and a fair amount about the going-on's of Marble Hornets. He also likely has a reason to be against Tim (as of now).
Logically, there only seem to be two people who fit the present bill for that: Alex and Brian. We know Alex has been living in Rosswood town for the entirety of the presently-experienced series (he moved from College-Town to Rosswood Town after giving the tapes).
-How Alex knows Tim's medical history
A little digging. It wouldn't be remarkably hard. Alex seemed rather suspicious when Tim brought him to the hospital. Something got him to beat Tim down with a piece of rebar. We also know that Alex went back to the hospital on several instances. Perhaps it was morbid fascination or even him playing Scooby Doo himself? Either way, Alex seems to have done his research on the town and going-on's, as evidence of his spooky story Entry 38 (not calling this an origin story, just observing it could be a town legend). At any rate, if the files were at the hospital, as Tim hoped in 66, Alex likely picked them up during 57.
-The Slender Doll
The only places we've seen the Slender Doll is at Alex and Brian's old house and inside the Maintenance Tunnel. Since the doll was left by Hoody, we can rule out that the doll at the house was Tim's; it was likely made by either Alex or Brian. We don't know that Brian wasn't experiencing the same symptoms as Alex, but the pictures that Jay picked up at the house are the same style as Alex's paranoid drawings, suggesting that he likely made the doll as well.
-The Tunnel Call
This suggests that Alex was following Tim and Jay, at least for this entry, and it also seems to suggest that he was trying to get them out of danger.
-Why Alex is against Tim
Besides trying to kill Alex with a rock, in Tim's own words "[he] started it." There was one early MH entry (with the burning forest painting) where the camera started distorting the moment Tim entered the room, coughing. I always felt that was proof that time was the "Alpha-Stalked" and brought it on everyone else.

Next I'm going to go over why the Hoody in Season 2 probably isn't the Hoody in Season 3:
-There is a remarkably large gap in Hoody's activity towards the end of Season 2:
The last time we see him on screen during Season 2 is Entry 45, where he lures Alex into the woods for the ambush. This is also the first/last time we see Tim and Hoody working together. The only other assumed video involving Hoody and Masky is Extraction, which judging by Tim's limp is old footage.
So the gap between Entry 45 and "Fragments", the first TTA video of season 2 is about late July to Feb 2nd. That's about a six month period. The biggest thing that happened during that six-month period is that Alex murdered someone.

I'll be the first to admit that while typing this out, I felt more and more silly, but I figured I ought to at least justify my initial thoughts. Sorry if I came across as a bit of a jerk, my girlfriend is the only other person I know who watches MH, so I was over-eager to discuss it. I won't be so jumpy in the future.

[Serum]

I know I sound like something of a hypocrite, but I'm starting to think Brian is the hooded figure, here's why...

The Hooded Figure seems to know a lot about Tim-- right down to his medical history. From what we learned in Entry 66, Tim said that Brian was the "first real friend" he had-- so Brian was someone he confided in and probably told him a little or a lot about his life. Then there's their mutual friend, Alex-- who came up with the idea for Marble Hornets, a movie, but after shooting it for awhile-- particularly when Tim was on set (something I've noticed from the earlier entries) Alex became increasingly agitated. Then there was the infamous "car entry" where Brian gives his "loop of unhappiness" speech, then the Operator is behind his head.

It could very well be that Tim "infected" Brian with the Operator, and in turn infected Alex and the set of Marble Hornets. It's also possible that the reason Tim was drawn to Brian is that Brian may have had similar Slendy-issues. Either way, Tim seems to be the reason that Marble Hornets went out of production and how Alex became obsessed with the Operator, stalked by him and now possibly living in the Dark World with him, or wherever he made that phone call from in Entry 64. Also, just look at Hoody-- he's a big guy, built like a quarterback-- there is another Marble Hornets character who fits that physique-- and it's Brian.

[Wubblz]

I know this isn't the thread to necessarily talk about Brian as Hoody (as I feel that most signs realistically point to Brian being Hoody), but the only real question I have is why Brian would suddenly be working to "expose" Tim's past with words as inflammatory as "He Is A Liar" if they are close friends.

But I don't think it's a crazy theory to suggest Hoody is Brian, and I'd say that it is the most likely answer. I think most in-game "hints" and OOG "hints" point to Brian having a larger role in the greater story, and he certainly has the most history and motivation of any character to be Hoody.

[Serum]

[MarbleArk]

My crazy theory is that Sarah will come back at least once, If that is to show her death, or if she plays a higher role, I don't know. I just have a feeling we'll see her at least once more.

[Serum]

[Tharol]

People say Jessica got knocked up by Jay reason she is not on video.

[CraicIsMighty]