unforum

[Janthran]

Anyway, can we all agree that Tim remembers his masky state now?

[Malckeor]

[Serum]

[Marble Hornets]

[UnQuantifiable]

I'll reiterate for those who missed my post from before. Tim doesn't know about his actions as Masky since before looking up Marble Hornets on the internet. He now knows what happens thanks to Jay's entries. Understandably he's pissed about it. It continues but he still doesn't remember. Sort of like watching yourself drive from the backseat (and nobody likes backseat drivers ). Tim looking all worried and sad at the beginning of 75 was probably cause he recently remembered about Jessica on that tape. Somewhere in the late 60's or early 70 entries is when Tim begins to remember his actions. I don't think it's as early as 33 (when 76 took place). It was much later.

[rab1s]

Holy crap. Awesome entry

I have a few thoughts though.

I dont think Jessica is dead. Hear me out.

We never saw her actually be killed.
"But the opperator took her!"
Yes but remember what happened to our friend Tim at the tunnel when he dawned the chest cam? He seemed to be taken. He even saw that guy that was beaten. But he made it back out.

Now i know that Tim's meds have magical powers against Slendy but what if shes in there, trying to fight her way out. Or maybe shes already out. TTA seems to think shes still alive. If this is 2 years ago, then by the time TTA said "Shes out there" a whole lot of time has passed.

Or maybe, since Jay is now on the meds too, maybe him (with or without Tim) will willingly be "Operated" and try to pull Jessica out as a Finalle. I dont know about you but i think that'd be awesome

[TheOperator]

[Marble Hornets]

Like I said in another topic, about 2 weeks ago I rewatched season 3 with the notion that Tim was lying about pretty much everything he said. Nothing really major came of it.

[kralyk]

WOW! What an entry!

There's seriously some excellent filmmaking in this entry, as well as acting.

[TheOperator]

[Janthran]

[DHawk314]

I think it's jumping the gun a bit to say this proves Tim and Masky aren't separate personas. At the end of the entry we see Tim on frame, and take the mask off. He seem confused. To me, the implication was that he then found the camera and watched the tape on the camera, but doesn't remember actually doing what he did on it as Masky.

To those who say that Tim said that he didn't have a camera to watch the tapes from 2006 in Entry #54, there are countless possible explanations for that. For instance perhaps it's a different kind of camera and a different kind of tape. But the most likely is that Entry #54 takes place 2 years after this and it's possible Tim just straight up lost the camera, or since it's Hoody's that he took it back. Frankly, why would he keep it for two years after he watched the tape? He may have just watched the footage there in the park, took the tape, and left the camera.

So what's my theory? I think saying Tim was lying about not remembering being Masky is kind of a stretch. It would mean he was playing Jay this whole time, which would just generally be kind of convoluted. I think Tim watched the tape, but didn't mention it to Jay when they met in Entry #53 because Jay was claiming to just be some guy remaking a movie. Why would he care about some girl Tim took into the woods where she died(?)? Tim had no idea Jay was even connected to the whole thing.

The only flaws in this theory are that Alex says to Jessica "It's all Jay's fault" on the tape, but there are a lot of Jay's in the world, it didn't have to be the one he and Alex worked on the movie with, from Tim's perspective. I don't blame him for not making the connection. And of course if Tim knew Alex was a crazy murderer, wouldn't he be more suspicious of helping Jay finish Alex's movie? That flaw's a little harder to work out, but it's possible that he genuinely thought Jay didn't know and had good intentions, until he eventually became suspicious. Or perhaps he didn't know that the Alex on the tape who killed Jessica was the same Alex as the one who made Marble Hornets - perhaps he forgot what Alex looked like? I know that's a bit of a stretch but Jessica forgot where she lived, so it's plausible.

Overall, I doubt these micro questions will ever be answered, but I do think it'll turn out Tim was't lying about not remembering being Masky. This, in my opinion, works very elegantly, as totheark/Hoody only started calling Tim a "Liar" after Entry #59. Which of course, could be attributed to this line of dialogue.

[Serum]

[Amethyst.64]

[Marble Hornets]