unforum

[Flyleaf(IntoTheMist)Wolfi]

I would like to point out that TTA could be "accidentally lying". He doesn't know if she's actually alive, so he says what he would like to believe. Its very likely that it could be true, but could also be the exact opposite. Telling Jay this gives him hope that he could find her vs the 'I haven't heard anything from/about her in almost 2 years whats the point?' mentality that most people in his position would probably have.

Also, the whole Tim not giving Jay the tape thing. Yes, he knows whats on the tape. No that doesn't automatically mean that he knows what happens while in his masked state. It was two years ago, even if he knew, i don't think that he would have remembered. He had to have watched the tape more recently. Also if I knew what was on that tape, I wouldn't actively give it to Jay either. He's in a compromised state of mind, and should be given time to come back to his senses before having a bombshell dropped on him. Hopefully the fact that he uploaded the tape means that he hasn't completely lost it.

Going on to Jess's state of being: there is just as good a chance that shes alive as she is dead.
Sure, she was breathing, does that mean that she doesn't have a wound off cam that shes bleeding from? Or that her actress can hold her breath that good?
She also could have been sent to the little 'pocket dimension' that has been talked about. There she could have woken up and tried to escape(she could either still be there or out in the real world, not knowing jack about MH). Or maybe she's been slendeported to some random location.
Simply put, we just don't know. For now, she is Schrödinger's Jess. Neither outcome can be assumed until we are shown otherwise. Which hopefully we will be before the finale?

[searchanddestroy]

Just a quick observation. One thing I noticed is alex always apologized to Jessica before he was about to shoot her...twice. Jay on the other hand just gets yelled at by Alex for causing everything before he was supposed to be shot. It was never his intention to hurt Jessica, that's why he told her he found Amy. We see him pick up the gun from Jessica but never use it, he could've felt to guilty to go through with it. I think Jessica is one of the only people alex actually feels bad about trying to kill.

[TheJoker]

[TheSupremeFace]

It's okay, i'm blue now. I'm suddenly much more mature and cool.... NAWT! The green shall infect all

[TheJoker]

NEVER- Oh goddammit.

Side note, who do you guys think was playing Hoody in this entry? It obviously wasn't Tim or Joseph or Jessica, and it didn't look like Troy to me. I mean, I could be wrong about that, but he seemed bigger than Troy.

[Marble Hornets]

Given that Troy (the creator) speaks for hoody in the totheark videos, I think we can rule out hoody unintentionally lying.

[Marble Hornets]

[TheJoker]

[searchanddestroy]

Questions. Answers/therories would be appreciated.

[Omberto]

Every time the next entry is touted to reveal something game changing to the series:

[pipete21]

Re: Questions. Answers/therories would be appreciated.

[elford]

Amy probably doesn't remember Alex or where she lived, and Alex loves her still, so he doesn't want to mess up her life ( if she has one) by finding her.
That is my theory.

i say she probably lost her memory only b/c Jessica has also lost hers, but this is an assumption, so this is not so much a theory as speculation.

[LBfly]

I agree with the "8 pages game touch" at the end of the video and i LOVED it, made me feel inside the entry.

Im just curious about why Hoody wanted Jay to watch it. Perhaps he knows it is not what it seems, she's not dead.
Or perhaps he just meant "her body is still at the park" when he wrote "she's out there".
Or perhaps it was Tim who wrote the code on Jay's twitter and thats one more reason TTA calls him a liar.

[TheJoker]

[FalloutGhoul]

Should I point out Sha Noran's post again?