unforum

[MariahTedder]

[Serum]

[jenni42ld]

 

[SilentMedusa]

'Kay, more thoughts.

Tim is sticking to his claim that he doesn't remember his actions as the Masked Man. I believe him; Hoody is obsessed with exposing Tim as a liar, but has never refuted this particular claim.

Speaking of lies, I have a theory about why Hoody was pissed at Tim in Entry #73. He wasn't mad about Tim having the tape; he was mad he didn't have it. See, Hoody gave Tim the tape to show Jay. He put it off, because reasons. Then they left town. When Hoody found that tape and realized Tim and Jay had left indefinitely, maybe permanently, and Tim didn't bring the tape with him, he took that to mean Tim intended to never show it to Jay. Thus, making him a liar.

After the rather startling reveal that Tim is now creating, editing, and uploading entries, someone put forth the idea that Tim has been posting entries all along, and all the events of Marble Hornets (including the "present" ones) take place in the past. I did this , but I've since noticed something. The text Jay puts in entries has little emotion; it's very dry. It reads like he's making a documentary, ironically enough. That's Jay's 'voice'. A written text from Tim should be very different, since his personality, speaking style, etc., are different. Plus, unlike Jay, he doesn't have any ingrained film school habits to creep into his narrative. But they aren't different. They read exactly the same. In fact, if he hadn't referred to Jay in third-person, I wouldn't have realized it wasn't a message from Jay. Also, in the description, it just has the entry number. Just like when Jay does it. It's probably nothing, but paranoia is part of being a Marble Hornets fan, right ?

I think it's telling that even after Jay tried to attack him with a knife, Tim was clearly trying not to hurt Jay. He easily could've beaten him unconscious, but he didn't even really manhandle him until Jay 1), didn't sit down when told to, and 2) lunged to grab his knife off the counter. That tells me that while Tim might not've handled things in the best way, he's probably not a bad guy. Not really.

Extraneous detail: when Tim tossed the knife on the counter, I saw Jay's flashlight laying there. It's not in the exact same spot, and it's resting on top of a folder, so maybe Tim was using it for something. Still, the idea that Jay's flashlight was still right where he left it 2 months before creeps me out for reasons I can't quite define.

[SilentMedusa]

[Beidah]

I don't think there's been enough discussion on Jay demanding Tim to leave the camera. Remember when Set turned off the camera back in season 1, entry #9 I want to say, and Alex freaked out on him.

[SilentMedusa]

That's a good point. I was wondering what Jay thought he was going to do with his hands bound; he sure wasn't going to film anything.

[Wubblz]

[twistedpuppet]

[Beidah]

[Hazman]

Lucky for me, I don't have a closet.

[TheOperator]

[Sha Noran]

DHawk314's long post on page 17 was pretty awesome.

[Amethyst.64]

[FalloutGhoul]