unforum

[CraicIsMighty]

So who died and made Tim a doctor? First giving Jay prescription medication without his consent, now stealing Jay's property "for his own good", Tim should open his own practice.

[Marble Hornets]

[gennerx]

[TheJoker]

Well, regarding the pills, he could have just tried and get them from whichever doctor prescribed them to him originally under the same reasoning he used then.

Speaking of which, I never understood, why did Tim need to go to his house to restock on pills anyway? If they were heading all the way to Rosswood Town to get them, they'd probably have been close enough to just visit his doctor and refill anyway. I mean, yes, he was probably more concerned with the tape and with Alex than with the pills, but it was a kinda crappy excuse to begin with.

[Ztakk]

[geekgirlinthefedora]

[DHawk314]

[Sha Noran]

[SilentMedusa]

In the spirit of over-thinking, I present a half-baked idea I've had since the first time I saw this entry: what if Jay's "we need to talk" Tweet wasn't the prelude to #77, but the aftermath?

I gave this a little more credence after everyone pretty much agreed a couple pages ago that Jay would've been able to free himself not long after Tim left.

The events of #77 happened. Tim comes home to find Jay gone, and spends the next hour or so searching his house for yet another psychopath lying in wait for him. Jay, meanwhile has time to think things over. He tries calling Tim, who ignores him. So Jay goes to Twitter. No mention of the incident, no apology, nothing. Just a demand for contact. Maybe he's snapped out of what was wrong with him, or maybe he's moved Tim's name to the top of his "to kill with death" list. The point is, he was planning to act like nothing had happened since #75 that would make Tim not talk to him.

Tim sees this, and uploads #77. Not to keep us informed of their 'investigation', but to show us that all is not as Jay says it is. To give us a heads-up that if Jay were to let's say, claim that Tim had turned on him, and been up to no good from the start, we can't just assume that's true. Indeed, Jay's the one who tried to attack him with a knife.

Reading Tim's text at the end, it's clear he was trying justify his actions and convince us that he's not the bad guy in this. Which makes me wonder why he cares what a bunch of strangers on the internet think of him, but that's probably a subject for a different thread.

And no, this isn't a serious theory, just an idea I found interesting.

[Amethyst.64]

[Katsatitagain]

Serious or not Medusa, I quite liked it. I've been wondering that too. While I wouldn't put it past them for doing another, -obviously something hass happened right after this entry, but it isn't posted till weeks later but is supposed to be taken as right away scenario- I think its quite possible that Entry 78 has happened already, and possible happened before 77 was even posted. After all, I don't think Tim thinks like Jay, about "if something happens to me, I need to post this first"

Or maybe I'm just half-baking another muffin from your idea.

[SilentMedusa]

@Amethyst: That's the problem. Now that we know for fact that Tim has and will lie if he thinks it's justified, everything he says and does is suspect.

[Beidah]

Ya know, if Tim had given Jay the video when he first got it, things wouldn't have gotten out of hand like this. Unfortunately, Jay didn't get the video until after he started getting more mentally unstable.

[Marble Hornets]

The video showed Tim and Hoody using Jessica to lure out Alex. Jay wouldn't have liked it no matter when he was shown it.

[Beidah]

That's not quite what the video showed. People keep saying, "Why else were they taking her to the forest?", but they forget that Hoody seems to have a magical disappearing hut out there. Also, Jay believed Tim when he said he doesn't remember being Masky, so why would Jay be mad at this thing that Masky did when he isn't mad at Tim for attacking him?