Return to Unfiction unforum
 a.r.g.b.b 
FAQ FAQ   Search Search 
 
Welcome!
New users, PLEASE read these forum guidelines. New posters, SEARCH before posting and read these rules before posting your killer new campaign. New players may also wish to peruse the ARG Player Tutorial.

All users must abide by the Terms of Service.
Website Restoration Project
This archiving project is a collaboration between Unfiction and Sean Stacey (SpaceBass), Brian Enigma (BrianEnigma), and Laura E. Hall (lehall) with
the Center for Immersive Arts.
Announcements
This is a static snapshot of the
Unfiction forums, as of
July 23, 2017.
This site is intended as an archive to chronicle the history of Alternate Reality Games.
 
The time now is Fri Nov 15, 2024 4:15 pm
All times are UTC - 4 (DST in action)
View posts in this forum since last visit
View unanswered posts in this forum
Calendar
 Forum index » Meta » General META Discussion
ARG or NOT
Moderators: imbri, ndemeter
View previous topicView next topic
Page 1 of 2 [27 Posts]   Goto page: 1, 2 Next
Author Message
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas

ARG or NOT
Introductions - My Interest in Collective Intelligence, ARGs and the suicide of Theresa Duncan

ARG or NOT: "Introductions - My Interest in Collective Intelligence and ARGs for Espionage"

Greetings, Howdy and Happy Thanksgiving!

My Name is Stephen Miles Lewis and I've been interested in posting here since at least January of this year. I just posted a brief introduction here:

http://forums.unfiction.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=421499#421499

Since going BACK down the ARG Hole this past year I've seen several areas of interest to me re-converge such that I truly NEED to communicate with this wonderful community.

This is a rather complicated story with so many threads I'm not sure where to begin. The link above gives a VERY brief intro to my odyssey that spans from early 2001 to these past few months.

I'm going to go ahead and post this thread and add to it shortly.

SMiles
www.ELFIS.net
www.SMilesLewis.com

PostPosted: Thu Nov 22, 2007 5:11 pm
Last edited by elfis on Sun Dec 16, 2007 11:05 pm; edited 1 time in total
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Star Spider
Veteran


Joined: 20 Apr 2007
Posts: 148

Hey!

Hey Smiles!

That was quite the friendly post Smile Nice to see! I am pretty new to posting round here but I thought I would say welcome!

So what is the story? That is a lot of info you got there and I am not sure what it is all about... care to explain?

Very Happy

PostPosted: Thu Nov 22, 2007 5:46 pm
 View user's profile Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
 Back to top 
FLmutant
Decorated


Joined: 29 Oct 2004
Posts: 244
Location: Orlando, FL

Re: ARG or NOT
Introductions - My Interest in Collective Intelligence and ARGs for Espionage

elfis wrote:
ARG or NOT: "Introductions - My Interest in Collective Intelligence and ARGs for Espionage"


Welcome aboard: I checked out a few of your links, and I kinda follow your chain of thought (I was a Paranet researcher back in the late 1980s and early 1990s and am also a bit of a Fortean.) They sort of dance around a point, but I'm fascinated to hear what point that is for you.

So you wonder whether or not ARG's mixing of reality and fiction might hide conscious fiddling of a disinformational sense? I totally get the accidental mixing being a concern, but tend to think that ARGs make great propaganda and horrible disinformation. Disinformation relies more upon suppressing curiousity than redirecting it, and ARGs are all about stimulating and directing curiousity. Fiction, I imagine, beats in the heart of every disinformationst to some degree?

PostPosted: Thu Nov 22, 2007 9:21 pm
 View user's profile Visit poster's website
 Back to top 
jjason
Veteran


Joined: 19 Apr 2007
Posts: 113
Location: St. Paul

Based on some of the links you gave you might be interesting in Dave Szulborski's series on the Dark Side of Args over at Alterati. For some reason it's been all converted into one big pile of text (I could've sworn there were paragraphs the first I read it) but besides that it's good reading.

On the subject of ARGs for espionage, have you read Halting State by Charles Stross? There's some interesting thoughts on how games and international politics might interact. See the spoiler for more info, with the caveat that it'll ruin one of the books big reveals.
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
There is an ARG-like spy game (which is honestly more like SF0 than what's normally thought of as an ARG) involving people pretending to be spies, sneaking around, following people, transporting boxes, etc that later turns out to be run by actual intelligence agencies, who are using the players to do tasks/gather information for them.


PostPosted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 1:31 am
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas

Howdy Star Spider, FLmutant and JJason!

Thank you so much for the warm welcome. You are already offering some good insights and food for thought.

GOSH! Where to begin?

Well first off ... I've been lurking a while and yet I've not figured out the code for doing the anti-spoiler roll-over code. Oh, but now I see the button marked SPOILER.

Well now, let me just re-address each of you fine folks who've commented so far:

- Star Spider: thanks again for the welcome. Nice to know there are other newbies around. I see by your website that you are involved in coordinating one type of real-world chaotic fiction style events. Very cool. Nice niche.

"What it is all about" ...

Generally: It's about me fleshing out my thoughts and experiences of the past quarter year. It's about engaging folks who are active within this community to get their take on things. It's about educating myself about your community and about educating your community about these multiple strange threads that I think should make a great META conversation. It's about exploring the Collective Intelligence of gamers, internet researchers, cyber sleuths and perhaps making real world discoveries and solving real world crimes. All the while hopefully gaining a detailed enough assessment of things to bring a concise synopsis of the interestingness and import of these issues to the unwashed masses. It's about the internet, identity, art, mystery, crime, and exposing corruption and criminality.

Specifically: It's about the mysterious double suicides of two exceptionally interesting artists whose legacy is a veritable synchronicity driver and jumping off point for a variety of art movements, parapolitical activist networks, and paranormal research directions.

More specifically: It's about Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake who believed they were, 1 - being harassed by Scientologists, 2 - were possibly tied to MK-Ultra childhood mind control experiments and SRA (satanic ritual abuse) networks and, 3 - were very saavy regarding certain art movements and magickal traditions interested in effecting change through memetic engineering and morphic resonance. They had fled California to escape the perceived harassment and were living within the famous parapolitically charged atmosphere of St. Mark's Church in the bowery of NYC where Project Censored award winning activist and 911 Truther Rev/Pastor Frank Morales had let them stay in the sanctuary of the church rectory where Theresa killed herself.

Due to some very specific backstory involving parapolitical blogger Ty Brown of the DreamsEnd blog, Ty became convinced that Theresa Duncan's blog, the Wit Of The Staricase (aka WOTS), was a rabbit hole for an elaborate ARG. In the course of researching the case and her blog some very strange "internet shenanigans" began occurring that intimated a real ARG or LARP (or LARG?") that either sprang up in response to the blogger's theory or is/was actually part of the supposed game. That blogger, Ty Brown, has since pulled the plug temporarily on his blog and has made the forum that developed around this case's exploration private. You can read all his PRE - "Theremy Saga" writings here:

http://dreamsendweb.com
http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://dreamsend.wordpress.com/
http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://dreamsend.blogspot.com/
http://dreamsend2.freeforums.org

- FLmutanat: thanks for the welcomes.

FLmutant wrote:
Welcome aboard: I checked out a few of your links, and I kinda follow your chain of thought (I was a Paranet researcher back in the late 1980s and early 1990s and am also a bit of a Fortean.) They sort of dance around a point, but I'm fascinated to hear what point that is for you.


I figured there had to be some Forteans, Anomalists, and other types of Informationalist counter-culture types in this gaming community. Can't wait to talk more with you.

FLmutant wrote:
So you wonder whether or not ARG's mixing of reality and fiction might hide conscious fiddling of a disinformational sense? I totally get the accidental mixing being a concern, but tend to think that ARGs make great propaganda and horrible disinformation. Disinformation relies more upon suppressing curiousity than redirecting it, and ARGs are all about stimulating and directing curiousity. Fiction, I imagine, beats in the heart of every disinformationst to some degree?


That is one aspect I am interested in. Psychological Warfare, PsyOps, Disinfo, Misinfo, Propaganda, InfoWar, Public Relations, Marketing, Advertising, Memetic Engineering, Social Engineering are all inter-related.

Part of the reason that the DreamsEnd blogger became convinced that the WOTS blog and the Theremy (Theresa --> Jeremy = Theremy) deaths were part of an ARG was due to his being preconditioned on the idea of ARGs being used as disinfo.

Back at the beginning of this year when I started re-investigating AboveTopSecret.com and posted at their forum about their historic connection to MAJESTIC I was approached by "Shawnna" regarding my research. I didn't end up communicating with her much. I was later to discover that the DreamsEnd blogger had not only been approached by Shawnna but was briefly recruited into her inner circle of parapolitical researchers who had been busy investigating the infamous SERPO ufo saga.

Quote:
Serpo - Shawnna and a friend's closing thoughts
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread211765/pg1

Shawnna's Truth Behind Serpo
http://serpo.info

REALITY uncovered Project Serpo Expose
http://realityuncovered.com/expose.shtml

Shawnna's Truth Behind Serpo
http://www.realitycovered.com


While within their inner circle at www.RealityCovered.com he found that one of the other anonymous researchers within that group (username KT aka KymTrail - [chemtrails were a part of the MAJESTIC game]) had amassed quite a threads worth of data on ARGs and their possible / probable use as a disinfo tool. So when he very shortly thereafter was exposed to the Theremy Saga via another arena of this story (Rigorous Intuition blog/forum of Canadian satirist Jeff Wells) he was primed to view WOTS as a rabbit hole. And a bunch of weird communications began flowing to him indicating that it was all an ARG - but perhaps an ARG with activists intentions to expose child sex trafficking, mind control, etc.

Basically, Shawnna and others say that the SERPO stuff is just the latest disinfo / counter-intel psyop by AFOSI agent Richard Doty. My good friend Greg Bishop is the author PROJECT BETA which deals with Richard Doty's and Bill Moore's UFO disinfo gambits against Paul Bennewitz that not only drove Bennewitz crazy but which would pretty much engineer the most prevalent UFO myths of our times:

Quote:

Project Beta: The Story of Paul Bennewitz, National Security, and the Creation of a Modern UFO Myth by Greg Bishop

A chilling, stranger-than-fiction nightmare about one man's ruin at the hands of a government bent on concealing the truth.

http://www.ExcludedMiddle.com


UFOMystic » SERPO Was A Big Fat Fake
http://www.ufomystic.com/wake-up-down-there/serpo-was-disinformation/

And the SERPO fanfare has actually been the subject of ARG-like viral/stealth marketing:

The Project SERPO Disinfo Gambit
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/03/12/the-project-serpo-disinfo-gambit/

Quote:

HOAXED 8mm film footage proves nothing about project "S"
daniel9223 = daniel davenport = bill taylor
( www.donatacom.com )
daniel davenport works for the interactive marketing firm THINK inc.
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread216167/pg3

Terry Heaton's PoMo Blog
06/19/2006 Entry: "A new form of entertainment"
http://donatacom.com/archives/00001379.htm


Yes FLmutant, fiction seems to beat at the heart of every disinfo agent:

Richard Doty and L. Ron Hubbard
http://redstarfilms.blogspot.com/2007/11/richard-doty-and-l-ron-hubbard.html

And as this forum community reported there is apparently a new ARG that is also marketing itself as an Espionage educational tool:

Never Rest
http://www.neverrestgame.com/downloads/documents/NeverRestGame.pdf

- JJason: Thanks for the welcome and thanks for looking over my previous posts.

jjason wrote:
Based on some of the links you gave you might be interesting in Dave Szulborski's series on the Dark Side of Args over at Alterati. For some reason it's been all converted into one big pile of text (I could've sworn there were paragraphs the first I read it) but besides that it's good reading.


I am familiar with that series. In fact, at least one or more of those articles was written in response to Ty Brown's writings on this issue.

One of the things I find most interesting about AlterNet is this fine article by another writer there which pretty much proves Ty Brown's point about the internet identity issues surrounding Theresa Duncan and the Art of Hoaxing One's Own Death:

Redefining The Real by James Curcio
http://www.alterati.com/blog/?p=1206
http://joinmycult.blogspot.com

jjason wrote:
On the subject of ARGs for espionage, have you read Halting State by Charles Stross? There's some interesting thoughts on how games and international politics might interact. See the spoiler for more info, with the caveat that it'll ruin one of the books big reveals.
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
There is an ARG-like spy game (which is honestly more like SF0 than what's normally thought of as an ARG) involving people pretending to be spies, sneaking around, following people, transporting boxes, etc that later turns out to be run by actual intelligence agencies, who are using the players to do tasks/gather information for them.


No I've not come across that book yet. Thanks for the ref and spoiler. Another book that has come up a LOT in this case is Thomas Phynchon's THE CRYING OF LOT 49.

I think this and many other models for the use / misuse of ARGs and gaming for Intel Operations is evident in geo-caching games and ARGs / LARPs like NeuroCam:

Neurocam: Australia's Latest Mystery
http://www.argn.com/archive/000191neurocam_australias_latest_mystery.php

NeuroCam
http://forums.unfiction.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8372

I even think a PKD (Philip Kindrid Dick) story dealt with a character who would play puzzles in the newspaper that were actually helping an Intel Agency precognitively predict where an alien/terrorist threat would pop up next.

Then there are the parapolitical intrigues of apparent internet shenanigans going on that may involve the cyber world equivalent of Gang Stalking ... in other words Forum Stalkers (singles and groups) who play mind games with folks on various forums, either as recreational RolePlaying or possibly as concerted PsyOp campaign against internet activists.

But I'll leave that and so much more for another post for now.

SMiles

PostPosted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 1:41 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas


ReCap of my interest in Theremy

Upon learning of their deaths I began the process of trying to know them (Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake) through the only avenue available ... their works. Theresa blogged her interests for the past 2 years so there are her writings there and elsewhere online. She produced animated shorts and computer games. I've been fascinated ever since.

http://theresalduncan.typepad.com
http://www.greylodge.org/gpc/?p=1109
http://archive.salon.com/21st/feature/1998/09/24feature.html
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/10/10/some-of-the-work-of-theresa-duncan-and-jeremy-blake/

Her long time boyfriend Jeremy Blake was my age and I've come to appreciate his work with video.

http://www.ktfgallery.com/artists/jeremy_blake/?show=bio
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/10/10/jeremy-blake-video-for-becks-round-the-bend/
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/10/10/jeremy-blakes-sodium-fox/
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/11/09/animated-painting/

In exploring the subjects the MSM decry as the couples collective and infectious paranoia one comes up against the question of whether something more than a double suicide has occurred here:

After the Ambulances Go - Rigorous Intuition
http://rigint.blogspot.com/2007/07/after-ambulances-go.html

Imitation of Life - Rigorous Intuition
http://rigint.blogspot.com/2007/07/imitation-of-life.html

The Trouble with Anna Gaskell - WOTS (archive.org)
Clicky Linky

Theresa Duncan's Mother on the Black Panthers and the Buried Idiom of Slavery and Discrimination - Alex Constantine (Froze this blog in Memorium to TD/JB)
http://alexconstantine.blogspot.com/2007/08/theresa-duncans-mother-on-black-pathers.html

The Murder of Theresa Duncan: Jim Cownie, Rupert Murdoch, the CIA, Cable Industry, Mind Control, Drugs & Political Assassination
http://alexconstantine.blogspot.com/2007/08/murder-of-theresa-duncan-jim-cownie.html

I've never really believed that their deaths were likely an ARG or Viral Marketing, per se. I have always been fascinated by the research process and the exploration of mystery and the mystery that was their lives is riddled with the various areas of inquiry that have obsessed me all my life. Mysteries like the interrelation of electricity with consciousness and perception, Rupert Sheldrake's morphic resonance hypothesis for formative causation, various magickal traditions, UFOs, parapolitics, government corruption and covert ops, the CIA's own obsession with Mind Kontrol techniques ranging from consciousness alteration through drugs and hypnosis to more exotic attempts using psychotronics (electromagnetics and parapsychological techniques and technologies), Cults, Religions, Belief, Myth and social control systems, September 11th and the individual and collective amateurs attempts at understanding each of these and more.

Whether one considers more seriously the Scientology angle, the Jim Cownie angle, or even simply the possibility that one or more individuals were messing with her mind and drove her over the edge. That is a very real possibility in my mind. Just take a look at some of these online shenanigans that involve false identity and lies and hoaxing:

Redefining The Real by James Curcio
http://joinmycult.blogspot.com/

Mo. City Outlaws Internet Harassment
http://apnews.myway.com/article/20071122/D8T2HHGG5.html

Suburban Counterterrorist Mom's Fake Online Identities
Behind Enemy Lines With a Suburban Counterterrorist
http://www.wired.com/politics/security/magazine/15-11/ff_rossmiller?currentPage=all
http://blog.wired.com/defense/2007/10/some-of-her-bes.html

Life and Death of Jesse Jubilee James, Featuring Harlan Ellison
http://www.anomalytv.com/site/2007/11/02/life-and-death-of-jesse-jubilee-james-featuring-harlan-ellison/

Fintan Dunne Investigating Steven Hertzberg of Election Science Institute and Ron Paul Online?
http://www.911activism.info/2007/09/03/breakfornews-steven-hertzberg-the-election-science-institute-ron-paul/

BreakForNews: Steven Hertzberg, the Election Science Institute, and RonPaulOnline.com
Clicky Linky

Fintan's Investigation of Steven Hertzberg
http://www.breakfornews.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=3498

The Trial of Kelvin Mace, aka David Allen, and other trolls
http://thetrialofkelvinmace.blogspot.com/2007/06/trial-of-kelvin-mace-begins.html

911 TruthSleuth Markus Allen Marketing Guru?
http://breakfornews.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=31482#31482


But the flip side to my fears and concerns over online shenanigans was watching Ty Brown of DreamsEnd and others out various individuals and groups who seemed to be part of some rather strange online exercises that may be individual wack-job mind-games or may actually be part of govt/corp attempts to derail unwanted activism.

When I read T. L. Taylor and Beth E. Kolkob's paper on BoundarySpaces and how the Collective Detective model emerged from the CloudMakers desire to translate their CyberSleuthing into real world crime fighting and mystery solving due to the tragic events of 911, I began to be re-energized by the ideas inherent in Collective Intelligence I'd already been witnessing as folks formed groups to research everything from Ghosts to UFOs to ESP to Crimes, Corruption and Conspiracy.

BOUNDARYSPACES : Majestic and the uncertain status of knowledge, community and self in a digital age by T. L. Taylor and Beth E. Kolkob
http://www.itu.dk/%7Etltaylor/papers/TaylorKolko-Majestic.pdf

Let's Be Serious: Non-Casual Investigations into Alternate Reality Gaming
http://retext.blogspot.com/2007/05/lets-be-serious-non-casual.html

The Majestic Game, Interactive Media Environments, and a New Turing Test: Blurring the Boundaries Between Virtual and Real by Damian Ward Hey
http://media-ecology.org/publications/MEA_proceedings/v3/Hey03.pdf

Viral Media: How It Can Work in Education
http://www.nostatic.com/viral/?q=node/27

Hewlett Viral Media Research Project
http://interactive.usc.edu/members/mtuters/2007/05/viral_media_research_project.html

Viral University Education (vue)
http://nostatic.com/hewlett/

But there are also always tricksters ...

Joseph Matheny - Cultural Provocateur - MediaKaos - FringeWare
http://www.sirbacon.org/content/76.txt

Garden of Truth on the El-Centro "ARG" plus Matheny interview
* Part 1: Milford Connolly introduction
* Part 2: Milford reads Chapter 1
* Part 3: Milford Reads Author Interview
* Part 4: Milford interviews author Joseph Matheny

http://el-centro.net
http://www.incunabula.org
http://gardenoftruth.org

Complete Podcast with Interview
http://www.theeggmovie.com/audio/El-Centro-96kbps.mp3

Transcript
http://www.theeggmovie.com/tran/31869-a.html

So to recap and expand thru statements and questions:

- Is this a simple and tragic case of a double suicide that just happens to be riddled with foreshadowing and synchronistic interconnections with the faux world of ART and ARGs?

- Or is there more intrigue to be found in their deaths? Were one or both of them murdered? Did one or both of them fake their own deaths?

- Can Collective and Open Source Intelligence and the ethos of the Collective Detective actually be used to solve real world crimes and mysteries? I and others think so.

That's all for now.

SMiles


[EDIT] Destretchified by reducing the really long URL a little Wink --Giskard

PostPosted: Fri Nov 23, 2007 7:36 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Silent
Boot

Joined: 05 Aug 2007
Posts: 56

Quote:
Can Collective and Open Source Intelligence and the ethos of the Collective Detective actually be used to solve real world crimes and mysteries? I and others think so.


NO!

There is a reason why criminal investigations are classified, why police are the only ones allowed to look at evidence. If everyone can become a cop, then it will just lead to viglitante justice (I hate that guy, he's the killer!), and worse, the actual criminal may join the game and 'gamejack' the Investigation (so they can live). They know the evidence against them, they'll go and then try to explain that evidence in a different light.

Real crimes are more complex than simple cases, and you always have to be careful of 'reasonable doubt', as you may be wrong. Trained professionals have been solving these cases for years, and you want to replace them with...us?

And what if the guy we accuse is declared innocent? Should we all be sued for being morons?

PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 12:39 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
catherwood
I Have 100 Cats and Smell of Wee

Joined: 25 Sep 2002
Posts: 4109
Location: Silicon Valley, CA

Silent wrote:
Quote:
Can Collective and Open Source Intelligence and the ethos of the Collective Detective actually be used to solve real world crimes and mysteries? I and others think so.


NO!

There is a reason why criminal investigations are classified, why police are the only ones allowed to look at evidence....

I certainly wouldn't want the general public getting involved in an ongoing investigation. But there are occasional cold cases which a police department does make available for the public to view evidence. Even then, they're only asking a "collective intelligence" to look for some detail they missed or patterns they didn't catch, at which point the professional detectives should take back the case and renew their efforts. The Collective will never be used to directly convict anyone.

PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 1:50 pm
 View user's profile AIM Address Yahoo Messenger
 Back to top 
Silent|away
Guest


catherwood wrote:
Silent wrote:
Quote:
Can Collective and Open Source Intelligence and the ethos of the Collective Detective actually be used to solve real world crimes and mysteries? I and others think so.


NO!

There is a reason why criminal investigations are classified, why police are the only ones allowed to look at evidence....

I certainly wouldn't want the general public getting involved in an ongoing investigation. But there are occasional cold cases which a police department does make available for the public to view evidence. Even then, they're only asking a "collective intelligence" to look for some detail they missed or patterns they didn't catch, at which point the professional detectives should take back the case and renew their efforts. The Collective will never be used to directly convict anyone.


Maybe. But I usually thought they do that in hope that members of the Collective Intelligence may in fact witnessed the crime and will come foward with evidence.

What you describe might be reasonable, but I'm still skeptical.

PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 3:09 pm
 Back to top 
vpisteve
Asshatministrator


Joined: 30 Sep 2002
Posts: 2441
Location: 1987

.......S@m???
_________________
Making the world a better place, one less mime at a time.

PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 3:25 pm
 View user's profile Visit poster's website Yahoo Messenger
 Back to top 
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas

Hi Silent and Catherwood! Thank you for sounding out on this thread.

I suspect that most folks have the same opinions as you two.

Of course I also think that the majority of people don't question authority enough.

Given the widespread amount of corruption and criminality in the world - especially among those in power, whether they be police, politicians or paper pushers, I think it unsafe and unwise to always "leave it up to the professionals".

Certainly there are clear examples of how one or more amateurs CAN contribute to the conviction of criminals. I gave at least one MSM example above:

Quote:
Suburban Counterterrorist Mom's Fake Online Identities
Behind Enemy Lines With a Suburban Counterterrorist
http://www.wired.com/politics/security/magazine/15-11/ff_rossmiller?currentPage=all
http://blog.wired.com/defense/2007/10/some-of-her-bes.html


The other examples I gave were of more mundane criminal activities; people impersonating others or creating false identity characters to manipulate others for their own good. Certainly the phenomena of AstroTurfing and SockPuppeting could be easily investigated online, reported upon to the proper authorities and charges brought based on the evidence gathered in the online investigation.

What I'm talking about is only a variant on the idea of Private Detectives (aka Private Eyes aka PIs for Private Investigator / Private Investigations) who might have specialized knowledge (and often do have the kind of Professional Police / Investigative background that critics of the Collective Detective idea say is required to be considered legitimate) and who often form their own professional Detective Collectives behind the scene as part of the PI Firm they work for, like Law firms.

Collective Detective groups wouldn't have to be completely open to the public like the beasting cloudmakers with a yahoo group from back in the day.

And what about Investigative Journalism? What skills or professional background are required to simply be a reporter who investigates crimes and writes articles about them. Certainly this is an age old problem, where a reporter must weigh the dangers publicizing details which could compromise a court case or ongoing investigation.

I guess I'm kind of a Muckraker at heart.

SMiles

PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 4:58 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas

Of course I'm not the only one wondering whether Collective Intelligence can be used to solve real world problems:

Quote:
Gamers have skills. Let's tap 'em.
Video games are training people to solve tough, real-world problems.
By Jane McGonigal

...

The term "collective intelligence" was coined by French philosopher Pierre Levy in 1994. He argued that, because the Internet allows a rapid, open, and global exchange of data and ideas, the network should "mobilize and coordinate the intelligence, experience, skills, wisdom, and imagination of humanity" in new and unexpected ways.

Thanks to the unique nature of digital gaming, gamers may be the world's most literate and practiced community when it comes to developing these new, real-world skills of collaboration and collective intelligence.

The emergence of a collective intelligence culture among video-gamers is not surprising when you consider that all games, even nondigital ones, are at heart both a social and a problem-solving activity – the two core ingredients of any collective-intelligence effort. Decades before the invention of video games, Albert Einstein, an avid chess player, wrote, "Games are the most elevated form of investigation."

...

Many game developers are starting to realize the potential of this new collaborative task force to tackle real-world issues as they play.

This spring, the Independent Television Service released an online game called World Without Oil, for which I was a lead designer. World Without Oil was designed to harness the collective intelligence of gamers and apply it to a serious global problem. It invited players to participate in a collaborative simulation of a global oil shortage. They spent six weeks investigating an online mystery that explained the reasons for the shortage. Then more than 1,800 gamers from 12 countries spent another 32 days generating their own stories about the crisis and strategizing ways to manage it.

During the game, players worked from a shared "alternate reality dashboard," which provided real-time data on oil prices and availability, as well as descriptions of their impact on regional economies, society, and quality of life. They used this data to inspire their own ideas about how the fictional crisis would affect them personally and play out in their part of the world. They contributed fictional firsthand experiences and proposed real-world solutions to our oil dependence in thousands of blog posts, podcasts, videos, and wiki articles. The result is an online, immersive archive of the collective forecast and solutions toolkit created by the players (which you can find at www.worldwithoutoil.org).

Read entire article here:
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/1105/p09s01-coop.html


Quote:
Collective Detective Police Work
Daniel Terdiman Email 03.02.05

...

In some situations, the public uses the web to take matters into its own hands. That happens when, for example, families of murder victims feel the police aren't making progress in solving the crimes. Thus, online sites like Real Crimes have come along, allowing people to publicize their own investigations and ask for help from the public.

While many of the cases posted on such sites go unsolved, some progress is often made because the people involved are eager to help each other follow paths police may not have considered.

"Since there are many cases on Real Crimes, we help each other, sharing information on how we searched the internet, what we discovered (and) who we could contact," said Pam Petrazzuoli, whose son's murder case was considered unsolvable by police. Thanks to Real Crimes, she said, an eyewitness in the case has come forward, though she acknowledged that the police have yet to accept the witness.

...

Some criminologists believe broad calls for public help can create more problems than they resolve. Florida State University criminology professor Cecil Greek said he thinks police only ask for the public's help when no further leads can be pursued.

"Once you start doing that," he said, "you might get a bunch of bad clues from people that think they're helping (that you have to) sift through to get to the good ones."

But David Lawrence, a detective in the El Dorado County Sheriff's Office in California, said the risk of getting a mountain of useless tips is worth it if something good comes in.

"You just have to accept that," Lawrence said. "To get a few pieces of good information, you're going to have to put up with a lot of crackpots and other bogus information. You really don't know what's good until you check it out."

http://www.wired.com/politics/security/news/2005/03/66684?currentPage=all


And whatever happened with the official Collective Detective that was founded here in my hometown by Holly Samee and Josh Babetski?

- SMiles

Quote:
Collective Detective Goes Live

AUSTIN, Tx. - Sept. 1, 2002 - Quixotic Bravado, Inc., a multi-media development and consulting company based in Austin, Tx., today launched Collective Detective (http://www.collectivedetective.org), the internet's premier provider of Distributed Investigative Environments (TM)

http://web.archive.org/web/20030613180728/http://deaddrop.us/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=7


PostPosted: Sat Nov 24, 2007 5:11 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Obtusitivity
Decorated


Joined: 05 Jun 2007
Posts: 193

Quote:
Can Collective and Open Source Intelligence and the ethos of the Collective Detective actually be used to solve real world crimes and mysteries? I and others think so.


I could see this as a possibility in the event that whoever is attempting to use this method properly places said scenario within the confines of *fiction* in order to ensure that the individuals within the collective, the departments and organizations involved, and the victims and perpatrators of such crimes have their rights protected, as well as keeping them entirely seperate from one another.

One thing to keep in mind that investigating real-world crimes, means coming into contact with real-world criminals, therefore putting every collaborative member within the system at risk.

PostPosted: Sun Nov 25, 2007 6:30 pm
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
dreams end
Guest


Matheny/Egg

The interview with Matheny Elfismiles refers to is entirely scripted. If you listen to the credits you will find they are read by someone who has a voice remarkably similar to the "host" of the program.

That person, called "the narrator" in the credits, is T. Emerson Williams. He was involved with Chasing the Wish among other things.

He's a talented artist and, judging from his creation of the character of Milford Connolly, a talented voice-actor as well.

The site maintained by "Connolly" is called "Garden of Truth". It is part of the resurrection of the El Centro Arg which is also being tied in with the Egg material created in the Incanabula/Ong's Hat Arg. Well, Matheny says this current incarnation is NOT an ARG...so I've settled on "NARG" as the term for his projects.

The interview is part of an 'audio book' which can be found, along with other items in this new project, here:
http://www.el-centro.net/

I have the unique distinction of being in the following little mini-rabbit hole. I penned some blog posts, currently off line due to naughty behavior by various gameplayers up to whatever it is they are up to, which suggested the Theresa Duncan and Jeremy Blake deaths were faked as part of the beginning of an alternate reality game or some other sophisticated online, distributed content art project.

Dave Szulborski penned several articles at Alterati denying this and taking offense at such accusations. These articles are one of the "exhibits" on el-centro.net.

What I'm saying is that the denunciation of my suggestion that certain topics were part of an ARG are now officially part of an ARG...or NARG, since Matheny says it's not an ARG. I think I get .5 added for degree of difficulty on that little maneuver.

Keep in mind that Matheny typically casts himself as a character in his own ARGs. Hence you can listen to him explicate the mysteries of Ong's Hat on the Art Bell show. All the while, JM is presenting himself as simply a seeker of truth.

By the way, if you go to the Garden of Truth link, check out the comments on the current article. You'll find one of the names to be the same BM mentioned by Elfismiles. Small world.

My blog goes back up at the New Year. I got so many people sending me emails under false pretenses, threatening to sue me, etc that I decided to pack it in the pickle jar and eat it later on this winter. My blog was not originally even about any of this stuff...but when you start looking into Duncan's death, the strangest things start happening.

I'm not sure yet if I'll have the forum back up at the new year or not. I don't really have time to monitor it.

As far as I can tell, there are maybe three people in the universe who believe my theory that the Duncan death was part of an elaborate media hoax for ARGish purposes. One of them is my hair stylist...and since I do tip her and everything, I guess I probably shouldn't count her. Even most of the folks on my own forum don't buy it.

Hey ho, hey ho, it's a pirate's life for me...

I thought when Duncan posted again at her famous blog some months after she died that this might be seen as rather convincing...but it turns out everyone thinks she just scheduled her Oct. 29 ghost story post ahead of time. Sue the post HAPPENS to be about a message from beyond the grave, but it's possible...typepad seems to allow this. She has another post coming on New Year's day, says the mysterious "editor" of her blog. The "editor" did not see fit to tell us what it was. Or WHO HE is.

In between games? Wanna work your chops on highly literate blog which may turn out to have nothing ARGish about it whatsoever?

Head to Duncan's old blog. If you aren't breathlessly waiting for "What is this Game" to pop come ought-eight, maybe you can check in to find out what New Year's post she has for us from beyond the grave.

http://theresalduncan.typepad.com/witostaircase/

PostPosted: Mon Nov 26, 2007 1:09 pm
 Back to top 
elfis
Boot


Joined: 08 Oct 2007
Posts: 27
Location: Tejas

So, I realize my two main posts here at Unfiction's Unforums (anybody go to FT's Unconvention?) laid out many threads to choose from, but I've been disappointed that noone has chosen the one strictly to do with Theresa Duncan and her WOTS blog. Nor DreamsEnd's ideas about same and their use / incorporation by Matheny.

Any comments on those subjects?

From the Matheny "interview" transcript:

Quote:
So I was still looking for kind of the end product of why I'd been doing this kind of things to begin with, and so I decided that I would do something that was sort of ARG-like, not really an ARG, and I made sure that when Dave and I did this, we made really sure that people at ARGN kind of let everybody know, sideways, without just coming out and saying that this is an experiment in fiction that looks like an ARG, but it's not really an ARG. I basically did that because I didn't want hardcore players from places like Unfiction and Collective Detective to come on board thinking that this was a full-scale ARG, but rather that this was kind of a concentric circle novel.

http://www.theeggmovie.com/tran/31869-a.html


sMiles

PostPosted: Sun Dec 02, 2007 11:25 am
 View user's profile
 Back to top 
Display posts from previous:   Sort by:   
Page 1 of 2 [27 Posts]   Goto page: 1, 2 Next
View previous topicView next topic
 Forum index » Meta » General META Discussion
Jump to:  

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
You cannot post calendar events in this forum



Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group