unforum

[det slanke mannen]

[YamaKami]

@det slanke mannen brought up some good points, as have a lot of other people. I was firmly in the "Alex cannot possibly be TTA" camp, but recently I've been considering it more and more - especially if we think about season 1 TTA and season 2 TTA as possibly different entities (since I firmly believe that Alex was off doing his own thing and happily not involved during season 1).

Still, the one thing that really bothers me about the Alex theory is *why* is he making these videos? We know that Alex came out of hiding and contacted Jay directly during the 7-month blackout. So he has no reason to hide himself now. Jay is still obviously involved in this and extremely confused. And TTA is showing signs of being frustrated that Jay isn't investigating or doing anything proactive. If present!TTA is Alex and wants Jay to get a move on and help him find Amy/defeat the Operator/etc., why not just go to him directly like last summer?

Serious question here - I'd love to hear some ideas about Alex's current motivations! Because I can't make heads or tails of them, and it's the one thing stopping me from fully embracing Alex=TTA as a plausible theory.

[TheArmadaBledd]

I honestly don't know how it is a valid theory, especially after 41 and 42... I mean think about it. In the dead of summer, Alex would have to park somewhere, dress up like that. Wander into the forest. Find Jay's camera, walk it back to his car, walk back to wherever he parked, dry off what would no doubt be a RIVER of sweat and make himself look presentable, then drive over, go BACK into the forest looking for Jay, and have the events of all those videos all play out.

Not to mention some people can see Hoodie -Who I'm Assuming Is TTA- leaning against a tree when Alex gets out of his car.

(As a note, I held it equal with the Brian theory up until 41, personally)

[YamaKami]

(Big supporter of the Brian theory here! )

The best way to explain the problems Hoody presents with the Alex theory would be to allow that perhaps Hoody is not TTA after all. Or that maybe Hoody is part of the team that makes up TTA. Because I do see Hoody sitting under that tree. And I also noticed how the camera pans over to that tree, centering that figure in the shot. IF Alex is TTA, and there's certainly evidence that Hoody is TTA, then maybe they are working together.

I'm just trying to logic out all possible sides though. Personally, I still think that Hoody=TTA and Alex=\=TTA.

(But I'm still curious about Alex's possible motives for making TTA vids! I want to believe, people!)

[det slanke mannen]

[YamaKami]

[theKVD]

[theKVD]

either way, I feel the look of shock was that SHE found it, not that it was there at all

[Chest Cam Avenger]

Loving the theories, guys. Not sure I agree with them, but it's keeping me on my toes.

@KVD - The main thing that's giving me pause is Amy's reaction to Slendy's appearance. I know I'm gonna get flamed for delving into the nuances of screams, but it definitely sounds more like a "OMGWTFAAAIIIIEEEE!!!!" sort of terror than a "Oh s***, not you again" sorta deal. Compare hers and Alex's reactions - he knows what to do because he's dealt with Slendy so much. If Alex and Amy had been together in Slendyville, wouldn't she at least be slightly familiar with him?

I AM curious about the use of the word "we", but I'm just thinking he moved long distance and she moved across town so they could live together.

Regarding the finding of the camera, I think that may be one of the more important parts of that whole video. Did he secretly bring the camera, was it placed there, did SHE secretly bring it...? I would love to know that.

[TheMuck]

This tta is a mysterious fellow indeed!

I am with the camp that tta is multiple people.

Not sure that masky=tta though.

There are entries where Masky is filming Jay in a vulnerable position and hanging out with hm as he sleeps. And other vids where he charges at Jay. (why not charge at him while he is down coughing, or smother him ini his sleep...?)

Maybe there is a "real Masky" who IS totheark, and an imposter (possibly working for the thin man). Has anyone ever compared the masks in different entries?

(sorry, I am new here, so this may have been covered - I have tried to read as many older posts as possible to be up to date on all theories..)

[Chest Cam Avenger]

[theKVD]

[TheMuck]

[dinosauring]

[theKVD]

as in perhaps Slendy was about to climb in his window and snatch him up? (couldn't resist the reference but honestly meant as a clarification question)