unforum

[Riovas]

[Dumbalias]

This is my theory up to Entry #45:

Ever since the one entry where Tim started taking those pills, and coughing, much like Alex did when in contact with slenderman around Entry #43, he was most likely the first one to get "slendersick." By slendersick, I mean, go insane, much like how Alex taped himself drawing the operator symbol, and writing strange things and drawing on those papers. Which, I believe to be the first step to being a "masky." Symptoms: drawing strange things, paranoid, coughing near slenderman, or coughing up blood, much like Alex in Entry #44. Also, "totheark," could not uneccesarily be Tim, but, maybe all of the maskies together, collaborating, or, he/she could be something unknown to us so far. As totheark mentions, that he/she is losing control, it leads me to believe that totheark is anti-slendy, considering that the maskies in Entry #45 ditched Alex once the ticker showed up on the video camera.

Maskies = Final stage of slendersickness
totheark = the one making the videos


Status:

Jay - getting suspicious of Alex
Alex - turning slendersick himself, which is why he could not tell Jay where he lives

Also, somebody earlier mentioned that the one figure looks a whole lot like Jay, which could be Jay blacking out and not knowing that he is a masky himself. Anyone could be doing it.

There are probably lots of typos and/or mistakes in this post, but, I just wanted to record my theories.

[12th]

Okay I'm sorry to be that guy, but let's take a step back from WELCOME TO THE ROCK debate.

Why does it matter whether it is the same rock or not?

[Riovas]

for this entry? it means nothing. But lets say it IS the same rock. Tim kept that rock for a couple of months. Why? maybe it is to help him remember what Alex did to him, or maybe it is what a masky does when it is in the mental state its in; it hoards things to keep their memories. And Tim didn't want to forget what Alex did to him, he needed to remember why he has a distrust and a hatred for Alex.

So if it isn't the same rock, no big deal.
If it IS the same rock, its maybe because that is how they keep track of their memories.

Of course, I completely BS that just now and its purely speculative, but it might fit into the story.

[Randoman96]

So a rock that Alex had to pick up with both hands now magically fits in one of Tim's hands? FUCKING AMAZING

[StarlitVixen]

[McGregor]

Ok I just want to say that it is not the same rock from entry 35. The rock from entry 35 looks like piece of cinderblock that is significantly larger then the rock Tim had. Tim was able to hold the rock with only one hand while Alex had to pick up the chunk with both.

Either way, why the hell does it matter anyway? A large rock to the face/leg will hurt either way.

If Tim did hold onto the rock for four months to get back at Alex, I wonder if Alex will hold onto it now to get Tim back this time. (Not being serious)

[George G]

I am sorry, but could anyone briefly summarize the reasons to believe the two rocks are the same except for "it would be cool if it was so"? They are more or less the same size, but that argument in itself is clearly insufficient - there's plenty of rocks of like that, and I can't think of any others.

[StarlitVixen]

I'm not arguing that it is the same rock.
I'm just getting annoyed with all the hate for people thinking there is absolutely no way it could be possible that the rock could be the same. It's funny how people can consider that there are words spelled out in tree branches but can't consider that TiMasky would save a rock for revenge. I would definitely do this.
Maybe I'm just annoyed because of all the trolls lately, but this has gotten under my skin for some reason.

[Randoman96]

@StarlitVixen

I wasn't saying Alex needed the strength, I was saying the rock was BIG enough that Alex needed both hands to hold it. Magically, it fits in one hand for Tim.

Fucking amazing.

[Nex]

I figure here's a good place to ask this:

Is anyone else a little...unnerved...at the silence from TTA.

No response between 44 and 45 was incredibly odd. He's never really missed a response before. And now it's looking like we'll be getting 46 today or tomorrow, and still, no response.

It's just odd, and for some reason it has me concerned.

[Riovas]

[Randoman96]

[Ryudragon]

Why oh why are we discussing if it's the same rock or not?

[Randoman96]

Because EVERYTHING MUST BE IMPORTANT