unforum

[Mariolee]

Calling it now. TTA is Tim, Brian, Alex, and one other person.

[MistrPibb]

[Mariolee]

[Zarggg]

Tim and Alex were clearly not on the best of terms during the missing months. I can't see them working together.

[Mariolee]

[Ceejie]

First time poster with a free Sunday and too who needed a distraction from chores.

I have a very long theory on who it is, and i'm going to post it in this thread as to not disturb anyone by creating an entirely new thread on this subject.

A word of warning: You're about to be bombarded with a wall of words that may require more than one post. You have been warned.

But first, I am going to post to TLDR version of my theory with none of the actual explanation in case you don't want to have to read the short story I am about to share with everyone.

[Ceejie]

Recently I have been looking back through the old entries more thoroughly and it has helped me form a theory on who I think totheark is. I think I have overwhelming evidence to my theory, but I would like others to look over it and see what they think, because it's no fun if I don't share my findings, is it?

In order to have a full scope of who ToTheArk may be, we will need to review all of the ToTheArk videos, and what they refer to directly.

Hopefully I haven't just spent an afternoon on something that someone else has already fully realized and I am just blowing hot air and wasting space here.

Let's start at the beginning, shall we?


Regards:

This first entry in the ToTheArk series of videos is very basic. The video tells it's intended viewer in code to 'look closely'.

What I want to address about regards though in relation to my theory, is the title of the video itself.

The title is often how one would end a formal letter 'back in the day' to someone they have had contact with, but weren't overly familiar with. "Regards, Bob", or "Best Regards, Jane." If we are to assume this is the meaning of the title, then this right out of the gate can explain the user name. These are meant to be addressed to an individial person.

"To: The Ark.

Look Closely.

Regards, your newly acquainted friend."


Operator:

This video is also pretty basic. It tells it's intended viewer to 'listen'. It contains audio that seems as if it could be the missing audio from entry 10.

I would however, like to point out the riddle in which ToTheArk tells us to listen, because I think there is more to it than was ever initially thought.

The riddle itself is:
Lakes
In Stillnesss will
Take
Every
life
of the
Night

The title of this video is eventually revealed to be the name of the entity we are viewing along with Jay in these videos.

Deluge:

The fourth video in the series, this video contains the messaging "WATCHING YOU", with the word 'You' in bolded letters for emphasis. The audio is said to contain the word 'Alex' as if being said by a female voice if you play it in reverse, but other than this very little has been gleened from this video.

My theory as it why goes back to ToTheArk's user name and what it would represent should my theory be right. If ToTheArk really means " To: The Ark", then this video is meant to convey the following.

"To: The Ark.

You've been watching me. Now i'm watching YOU."

I would also like to address the meaning of the word deluge. Deluge means water overtaking the land, like in a flood or a heavy rain.

Entry 12:

The gang is out in a clearing at Rosswood, doing a bit of filming. A nondescript face can be seen in the distance of the shot, and the camera girl is a bit putoff at him being there. Alex tells her to ignore him, he'll wander off. But when she goes to see if he's left the background yet, he is even closer still. She sighs a bit in exasperation, and Alex says he'll go talk to the guy, then runs off to do so.

J expressed via youtube messages to a viewer of marble hornets that he thought entry 12 might have more video due to the fact there was still four or five minutes of tape left, but he hasn't been able to find it on another tape anywhere.

Impurity:

In Impurity, we are shown filmed video of a thunderstorm, and a coded message hidden in zeros that says "There was more."

The word Operator appears again in this video as well.

This video literally states that there *was* more, it's just not there, for reasons that ToTheArk apparently doesn't feel like explaining.

Entry 13:
Alex asks Jay to run back to the car and get something, so Jay does. As Alex is alone, he encounters the Operator not once, but twice.

Exit:
The video starts with an anagram for the word "Operator". It shows Jay retrieving the object from the car that Alex asked him to get. Considering Alex was the only one in the entire area that we are aware of trasping about with a camera, this footage is highly considered to be taken with Alex's camera.

When displayed in windows media player instead of you tube, the question "Where is the ark" is displayed.

Once again, if we take my initial theory that these videos are meant to be addressed to "The Ark" as an entity, and not as a place or thing, then the question can be translated as "Where are you?"

Entry 14:
We are greeted to a lovely view of Alex's bedroom door with no audio. After a few seconds, our favourite faceless entity comes strolling through. Alex reacts, but as he looks around the room he doesn't see anything.

Shutting off the lights, we presume he lays back down. 32 minutes pass and the tape changes, and we see Alex again bleeding profusely from his head and staring off camera.

Program:
Mostly this video is showing a image of a house, obscured by trees. It is reading, and an S is shown. In it we are given the message "Bleedmore" and "YAMA".

Bleed More could be referring to the previous video, in which Alex is caused to bleed by mysterious means. ToTheArk may be gleeful and happy at the fact that Alex was bleeding. Also, the word "YAMA" is found. Some associate it to the Hindu God of death, while others believe it to be an acryonym for "You Are My Ark". As you will see as this progresses I fall into camp two.

This is also the first appearance of an S symbol that I could find.

Entry 15:
Jay tricks Tim, one of the Marble Hornet actors, into talking with him about Marble Hornets under the guise of doing a screen test. However once Jay talks with Tim, his lack of deceptive social skills causes Tim to pull back into his shell when Jay wants to know about Alex's weird behavior, and, more to the point, the Operator. Tim denies any knowledge of the Operator, but his refusal doth protest quite a bit.

Advocate:
The video starts with the words 'tick tock' written upside down, then shows us a very poor image of Brian. The funny S symbol is present yet again.

The title of the video, Advocate, means 'a person who intercedes on the behalf of another'. Specifically, we could translate it as 'a person who speaks on behalf of another or acts as a mediator.'

Entry 16:

Jay decides to go to Brian's house. Arming himself with his camera and flashlight, Jay knocks on the door and then coughs. When no one answers, he tries the knob but finds it locked. Knocking two more times and trying the knob again, he relents that no one is answering, and gives the house a once over look before turning off his flashlight to go around back. Turning on his light again, he tries knocking on the sliding glass door in the back of the house, with still no answer.

This door is open though, so Jay takes the opportunity to invite himself in, and finds the place in severe disarray. As he looks around he calls out for Brian or Alex, with no response. Continuing his search, Jay discovers a closet with bedding, a water bottle, and the word "BONE" in it, hears some loud crashing sound, and basically hurp derps his way around the house. He eventually also discovered a sink full of dried blood, some of Alex's crazy drawings, a bullet casing, and some kind of medication. He leaves the house with the last three items, and a coughing fit, commenting he may eventually return.

Addition:

This is a video of Jay having one of his coughing fits in Brian's house, with the caption " SEE YOU". The video description is "//eyes\\"

The title is self explanatory. Whoever ToTheArk is, he was in the house when Jay was in the house and even though Jay did not see him, ToTheArk definitely saw Jay.

Signal:

Stock Footage of the movie "Silent Snow, Secret Snow" is shown. For a reference, this movie is about a boy who withdrawls from the normal world, instead deciding to live in a dream one filled with snow. No one else wants to indulge his obvious mental issues, and because of that he pulls away from his family and friends. He becomes increasingly irritable with everyone, locking himself in his room so he can live in his delusions of snow in solitude.

The audio used from this film in Signal is "Just wait 'til we're alone together, and I'll show you something new, something cold, something sleepy, something of cease and peace, and the long bright curve of space. Banish them, refuse to speak. Leave them. Go upstairs to your room. I will surround your bed. Close the windows, so that none will ever again be able to enter. I will be waiting for you."

Inbetween this footage, the intended viewer is told "Come Back" and "Find Me".

This is another video where the meaning of the title is pretty obvious. ToTheArk is sending a signal to "His Ark" to "Come and Find Him at Brian's House."

Entry 18:

Jay goes back to the house, this time, armed. He goes on again, and finds a doll errily similar to our friend the Operator. As he picks it up, Tim as his masked alter ego says "Boo." Jay, not knowing who it is, assumes it's Alex and gets all excited, before Tim *seemingly* attacks him. They struggle a bit, and Tim has a seizure for some reason. Jay tries to take the opening to remove Tim's mask, Tim screams the word "No", then tries to escape. His camera cuts out again, and he awakens in the middle of nowhere in his car, but without his knife.

Now, this is the crucial point in which when people started to believe that Tim and ToTheArk were the same individual, because ToTheArk asked Jay to come over to the house, and Tim happened to be there. While this is a decent natural assumption, it fails to acknowledge that this information is being posted all over the internet for the world to see, and Jay has already tipped off Tim that he is investigating the Operator again. I would like you to think of this from Tim's perspective for a moment.

You were being stalked by a monster, who you've figured out now thanks to videos on the internet, was only stalking you because this guy you didn't like (Alex) was provoking it. We can assume that all your friends from the shoot have been disappearing and acting crazy as well (Since Alex states this at one point), and that most of this died down after Alex took a walk and left town without a trace.

And now some jackass you vaguely know is poking the monster into coming back out hiding. If you didn't want to talk to Jay before about it, you probably wouldn't want to talk to him about it later either.

But what you might do is go out of your way to be where you know he is going to be, and stop him from doing anything stupid by whatever means necessary, including attacking him.

After Jay lost tape, he is found again elsewhere in his car. Either A: The Operator took him there, and for some strange reason robbed him of his knife.

Or

B: Tim took him there to safety away from the house, took the knife from Jay so incase Jay randomly woke he wouldn't get stabbed, and left him out there in the middle of nowhere where he thought Jay would be safe. If you are to assume all of the masked individuals are together, this would mirror behavior from the one we call "Hoody", and how he returned Jay's Camera to his car after he lost it in the woods.

Either way, this is our first hint that ToTheArk is not Tim.

Messages:

Images of a sinking ship are shown in correlation to Tim. Over all of this is the phrase "Tell Us. You have been keeping secrets. Smile for the camera."

Many people translate this at ToTheArk telling us that Jay has been hiding footage from us, but once again, given the facts we now know, why would Tim of all people be shown at the end of the video? If Tim and ToTheArk are the same person, why is Tim associating himself at all to ToTheArk? That seems like poor decision making.

"Hey yo this is Tim you should totally be telling us the truth bro"?

No. I believe this is the turning point in which the videos start addressing others besides "The Ark" and that this video is addressing Tim. I believe it is telling Tim " Tell us (The Ark and I) what kind of secrets you are keeping from us Tim, because I don't like this game."

Entry 19 or "Nice place you got here":

Jay reveals he has gone into paranoid taping much like Alex did. He says he doesn't find anything unusual, until one specific night.

This night after Jay falls asleep, Tim somehow shows up in his house. He shuts down Jay's camera, setting up his own next to it. he then proceeds to just hang around for a good length of time, bouncing around Jay's room at will. He takes a nice good shot of his mask. It is here the visual tearing starts again. Then the room is empty.

Jay says it stays that way for three hours until he returns and passes out immediately. He also says he suspects Tim to be ToTheArk.

But then again, who else would he have to suspect at this point? No one but Tim has shown themselves to him, not even Alex.

Once again, if we apply later videos to these ones, the logic of the Masks does not seem to be to hurt Jay. It seems to me since he just sat there watching him while he slept for a good chunk of time, this may have been an attempt by Tim to somehow protect him from the Operator. So long as Jay remains unconscious, he is vulnerable to the Operator's will (We have seen Alex fall asleep and wake up bleeding once already.)

Have you ever noticed how the entire video, Tim seems to make sure his back is to a wall and he is in a position where he can see the rest of the room? It isn't until he gets up close to the camera that the distortions begin again, and they both disappear. Perhaps he turned his back to the room at a bad time...

When Tim goes to check his camera for some reason ( I am guessing this is what he is *actually doing* when he gets quite close to the camera and not just filming his face, we have seen a number of similar shots from both Alex and Jay) is when the two of them disappear from the room and the digital camera comes back on.


Return:

In this video, we find out where Jay went. Apparently, he went into the hallway with the Operator to have bonding time.

The message in this video is very blatent. "Found You." with the added tagline of "Forever."

Now I know what you are wondering here. If Tim isn't the one who 'found him', who did? The only other logical conclusion is the Operator.

The Operator found him. And now, Jay has seen that which he cannot unsee with his very eyes. Which means the Operator has him in his cluthes, forever.

You see where I'm going with this yet? If you've actually managed to not fall asleep reading all this, then you should.

Version:
This video is discoloured, upside down footage of entry 5. The following words are hidden in zeros:

poison
random
endings
centered
excludes
death
encountering
stale
truth
receives
endangering
every
section

While I am sure these words separately are important, the first letter of each says 'precedestrees'. It is speculated that the word Operator is also in this video hidden in highly augmented morse code, and the words "Waiting for you" with emphasis on waiting and you.

ToTheArk wishes the intended viewer to know either one of two things.

Either A: That tower precedes (comes before) the forest surrounding it, which would make it more than just some fireman training equipment, or B: he wishes us to know that this entry precedes the one in which the Operator is seen in the trees/field in entry 12, but I am uncertain as to which message he is trying to convey at this time.

Attention:

Video of people traveling on bikes, as well as a soldier going to dispose of something played forwards than reverse is shown. The video sends the messages "Wake Up", "Return to Us" and "Awaiting You Arrival."

Many fans speculated that this was aimed at Jay, though if my theory is correct, this is one of the other few videos posted by ToTheArk that isn't addressed to Jay. It is an address to Alex.

Admission:

This video shows the Operator walking in front of the blinds at Brian's house, and one of the doors opening and shutting. It claims "There are doors left unopened."

Admission means to allow entrance. It is clear that whoever ToTheArk may be, he has enough authority in this situation to somehow allow Jay entrance to parts of the house that Jay could not previously enter for some reason.

Warning:
This video claims to be raw footage from Alex Kralie himself. This is the point at which people begin to suspect ToTheArk may be Alex. However, is there any evidence to show that ToTheArk may have just stolen this footage as he has been known to do in the past?

This video is some very frantic imagery not unlike the sort of thing we commonly see associated to Slender-sickness. It is, in essense, the horribly cryptic spooky doodles put into film form. Anyone we know so far or some who are not even introduced yet could have made this film in his/her sick state, and ToTheArk could just be using it to his advantage in much the same way he has done with stock footage. The video tells it's intended viewer to stay at home, keep his eyes open, and be alone.

It depicts what I believe to be The Operator capturing the masked man, which would mirror imagery from the entry before it. In the previous entry, when Tim and Jay run into each other in Brian's House, Tim once again does not harm Jay, but runs from him. Later, we see his mask, sans Tim, hanging from a doorknob.

Let us say for a moment that this video has been stole from someone else and placed on ToTheArk's account to put him at an advantage. Who would make such a video?

I submit that Tim, now captured by the Operator, made this video for ToTheArk under the influence of Slendersickness. The video is clear. Tim was captured, there is no one to help him (Jay) now. He should stay at home and hide. I notice that everytime we see Tim's mask, the imagery is either very tight or blurred (making it hard to tell *who* is wearing the mask, but for all we know it could still be Tim). The use of the "Alex krahlie's raw footage" quote, and "Smile for the camera" suggest the creator knows the other videos well. He also says to "Smile for Death".

Title of this one also seems obvious. It is a warning, though I believe it was meant as a warning to Jay, and ToTheArk corrupted it's meaning in order to use it to his advantage.

Entry ######:
I am noting this entry in the timeline not because I think it is by ToTheArk, but because others do and I think to make my theory correct, I am forced to debunk others as well.

This video shows multiple images of masks, which many believe to be more than one mask. It also focuses heavily on Tim. While this video *is* visually similar to previous video that had been posted by ToTheArk, it is worth noting that unlike *any* of the other videos, Tim actually talks in this video in a manner that does not need to be translated or decoded, sending a message to someone. For a ToTheArk entry, it is amazingly straightforward and coherent.

I believe Tim is sending a message directly to "ToTheArk", and not Jay. After all, Jay watches ToTheArk's every move, and he knows Tim has been in his house before, so hacking his account is not going to further gain ToTheArk anything. It would however, gain ToTheArk's attention if someone like Tim hacked Jay's account with a message directed at ToTheArk. Tim could easily just break into Jay's house as he has in the past, and upload the Video from Jay's own PC without him realizing until Jay himself saw the post.

Tim is shown putting on his jacket during the video, a common sign one is preparing themselves.

He states "We will wait for you no more. Control is being taken away from you. From the start this has been a game for us. Not anymore. I'm coming for you. And you will lead me to the ark."

I believe this video is addressing ToTheArk, letting him know through the course of everything, he has held all of the cards, but not anymore. Tim is sick of playing this game with him, and he is going to assure that the game ends by whatever means necessary. He will find ToTheArk and when he does, ToTheArk shall lead him 'to the ark'.

Fragments:

ToTheArk disappears for some time until the Fragments Video. It's description is 'hello again', and it's tags are "always" "See" and "You". It shows images of Alex being more and more destroyed, and the text says "You are broken" and "You cannot be fixed".

If we assume this video is meant to address Jay, then one can assume that ToTheArk is informing Jay that he is incapable of going back to a simple way of life. He has seen what he cannot unseen, and there is no return from that.

Alex's image may be used as symbolism to show Jay that this is what has happened to Alex, and it will be what happens to Jay. It could also be that ToTheArk wants to harm Alex, and this is why his picture is treated as such.

A fragment is an incomplete piece of a whole, perhaps suggesting that Alex, as well as others, are only pieces to a larger something.

Broadcast:

The visuals are of water, though weather under water footage looking up, or above water footage looking down is unclear. It's description is "are you drowning".

There is heavily distorted audio that says "Enjoying watching you suffer. Will you know me? I will always know you." The audio is later determined to be a text to speech program, meaning still to this point no voice has been conclusively pinned down as ToTheArk's real voice.

The word broadcast has two meanings. We are used to associating it to television and radio, but before either of these objects were invented, it meant to scatter or sow something over a broad area, such as plant seeds. This could suggest that something could've/has been planted in Jay from long distance.

Sidetone:

The description of this video is #000-0000. As we all know, dialing zero on your phone connects you to the operator, or it used to on landline phones. Shadows and furniture and a figure who appears to be the Operator are shown and the audio is Alex's voicemail box. He says to leave him a message and he'll get back to him, but over this the a numerical code which ends up spelling out the word "LIES".

Sidetone is a very unknown word and it is one I had to track down. Apparently, Sidetone is used to describe the sound of your voice in a telephone being reverted back at you. The phone companies when they were first starting had to find a name for this so they could describe whether the user was getting too much 'sideline' (could hear too much of their own voice coming back at them, causing them to lower their voice because they thought they were speaking too loud), or too much (Which caused a person to scream into the phone thinking they were talking too quietly and that the person on the other end couldn't hear them).

I suspect in this case it is referring to the fact that there is no sidetone (because Alex won't pick up), nor will there be.

I also want to address that this is the second time ToTheArk has suggested someone is untrustworthy. The first instance of this I can find is Citizen Ed addressing ToTheArk directly in the earlier days of his videos as to whether or not Jay is to be trusted. ToTheArk's response is 'human, therefore no'. One could take this as a very cynical comment from a very bitter person on the situation of society as a whole and how people are untrustworthy by nature, but one could equally take it as if the speaker is stating 'this is a human, humans cannot be trusted', and such a statement would suggest ToTheArk is either not human, or doesn't consider himself to be.

enttry 37 or "People without mouths will still show up to parties for free cake":

The description to this video is "memories". This is unusual because often times it is ToTheArk that posts only one word descriptives.

It is a video of Alex's birthday. There's a lot of normal birthday fare, right up until the Operator appears during Alex's candles being blown out.

The time stamp on the video freaks out thusly:

"JUN 3 1900, 8:23 PM"
"JULY 10 1999, 6:03 AM"
"AUG 30 1891, 1:00 PM"
"MAY 17 1988, 9:00 AM"
"SEP 4 1991, 10:48 AM"
"JAN 1 1992, 12:00 AM"
"FEB 29 1996, 4:44 AM"
"DEC 31 1999, 11:58 PM"
"MAR 3 1981, 9:42 AM"
"NOV 12 1993, 12:34 AM"
"JUN 6 1944, 9:99 AM"
"APR 4 1991, 6:03 PM."

As you can see, four of these dates preclude the modern day camcorder (Depending on what to consider that to be, I am going with the Betamax dates), though all of them exist within the timeline that cameras existed in some form.

This video I do believe was posted by ToTheArk from Jay's account. I believe the message was clear: "This game has been played for a very very very long time, both with Alex, and in general."

Forecast:
This is the video with the dog lung in it, and the extra footage taken by the person who is looking into Jay's car as he sleeps. The description is "see you saw you" encoded.

Over the lung is a number code which is found to spell out " A M I A P R O P H E T". I think the choice of a lung is interesting, considering that ToTheArk has commented earlier in his videos that Jay is drowning. Now we are shown a lung that is trying to be brought back to functioning order.

He tells Jay that there is something he'd like to show him, and it's video of Jay sleeping all snuggly in the back of his car, presumably taken by the person from the video before this one who passed his car at night. But was this ToTheArk? Or was this a Mask unassociated to ToTheArk simply keeping his/her eyes on Jay while he slept, much like I speculated Tim did in previous entries?

The forecast means to predict something happening. This title could mean to suggest that ToTheArk told Jay that Alex would abandon him, and Alex did.

Intermission:
This video asks the question "I saw you, did you see me?" With sketches of the forest in a style similar to the sort of thing a slendersick individual might depict situations they 'saw' but cannot talk about. It depicts a figure that appears to be a Mask hiding amoungst the trees. Some think this figure is meant to represent "There I was, right there. You didn't see me?"

I believe it is meant to goad the Masks. I believe it is meant to say " I saw you out there in the woods, but you are so in a tizzy now to acheive your goals, you didn't see me."

I think the title to this one is pretty obvious. It's a short break before the next part of the story unfolds itself.

Indicator:

The description to this one is "blind".

It shows images of a doll with markings similar to Tims mask burnt on it, and an operator phone key melted into it's eye. There appears to be saran wrap in the baby dolls mouth. This could be another sign of being deprived of air (like when you drown?)

There is text throughout the video of this doll shown wandering like a helpless child and being captured behind a picket fence that read as follows:

MESSAGES EVERYWHERE
SIGNS EVERYWHERE
YOU WILL NEVER BE FREE

There is more code which translates to "He Lies" (Surprise?) and the video ends. It seems to me that ToTheArk is trying to say that "Everything is telling you that you're not going to escape. Why do you keep trying?"

Memories:

The description is code for 54321, suggesting a countdown of sorts.

The video is black and white night footage. A bench is shown from two different angles. The words "YEARS WASTED" are shown, then two white lights that possible represent eyes. The next set of words is ""YOU'VE DONE" and then pauses, adding"NOTHING". which shows particular emphasis on the second statement.

Two boards are shown with oddly shaped a connecting S. One has a face with spinning stars for it's eyes. Then, the Operator symbol is placed over the face. Then:
SO MUCH
MORE
THAN TIME
HAS BEEN
TAKEN

The video ends with a close up of two white circles.

I believe the person being refered to here is Alex. He has been wasting years doing nothing that ToTheArk feels he should be doing.

I believe the title refers to what exactly has been taken.

Inquiry:

The very last up to this point in the series of ToTheArk Videos.

It shows series of what appears to be distorted faces. It tells the viewer to look at themselves, and that "they are who they are." An operator symbol is placed over one of these images of a person.

But "WHO ARE YOU?"

People speculate that the people in the photos look like Tim, Jay, and Alex. If they are, it is likely meant to engage them in asking "You are you, but who is that really? Do you even know anymore?"

This Video's description translates into "Minus Centroid", a Centroid being the central point in geometry where the straight lines meet in "X". Now keep in mind I sucked at math as a student, but if I remember right another way to say it, is that the centroid is akin to a linch pin of sorts. Without the centroid, you won't find X (the answer).

This is also where we see the phrase "DO I HELP OR DO I KILL?"

I believe ToTheArk is now debating whether he should help a character, or murder him. I would suspect Alex, but i'm not certain. If it IS Alex, then he may be suggesting by removing Alex from the picture violently, no one will ever have the answer.
----------------------

So now that we've reviewed all the material you can see where I am going with this, I hope.

ToTheArk is no one individual, because the individual who wants these messages sent has to use others to send the messages for him. ToTheArk is the Operator, or rather, it is a culmination of the messages the Operator wants sent that he cannot relate himself, so he uses other people to send them for him.

I suspect the first person to be used like this was Brian, judging by him being the focal point of "Advocate". But eventually, he moved onto using others.

[Chest Cam Avenger]

Thought about quoting the previous post in my comment, but I'm just not that cruel.

Um... Whoa, dude. Welcome to the forums!

Is it possible we can get that put into the wiki? I don't have the time to read it at the moment, and I'd hate to have to keep finding it again...

I'd save it to my computer, but I'm not sure I have enough hard drive space.

[Randoman96]

ffffttfffftfffffttffftttttfffff

Welcome to the forums, you've given me a seizure.

No but seriously, although I disagree with you, good work. It's nice to see people actually provide a good reason for their theories.

[MorbidPuppies]

^Very true, a welcome change from "I'm right because fuck you"

[Riovas]

oh god thats a long post and I don't have that much time right now to read it... will do so later after work. as for you TLDR, im very skeptical about slendy being TTA

[WhyYouBawwing]

^that's perfectly rational of you. we also would have accepted "No.....just no."

[Riovas]

[Ceejie]

I'mma kinda cut up my response post to Riovas so we are both on the same page as to what I am replying to exactly.

I wanna start by saying i'm sorry it took you 2 hours to read the post/debunk it/whatever, but I *did* give a TLDR for a reason. So you could once over my idea, and go "That's stupid" and move on if the reader so chose. I wouldn't have continued to post the same line of logic like *some people* on here if no one wanted to debate or talk about it or whatever, I just would have went back to quietly lurking. The only reason I felt like my theory needed every last minor detail explained, is if I just came in and posted it with no explanation, there would have been no real dialogue at all on the subject, which seems kinda silly on a discussion forum to me.

Anything I didn't reply to I didn't think was that open for counterargument. I'm not ignoring you, I just don't see a point in posting "Yeah you're not wrong, but it could be interpreted my way too!" over and over. So assume if I didn't respond I am conceding that I may be 'assuming too much' at this point and only pointed it out originally to show you were my logic was leading.

[Mariolee]

Thanks a lot guys, you just blew my mind. Do you know how crappy the warranty on those are?