unforum

[The Slender Man]

I'm sorry, Cougar Draven, but how does Decay prove that only one person is TTA?

[Jamocha101]

[pravado]

if pattern repeats (troy giving us screenshot on friday, uploading on sunday) we will have an entry tonight

[Susil]

[Andvalli]

[dinorobo]

Ok, I have a theory here, and its pretty crazy but bear with me.

We know from the Joseph Touches a Grapefruit video that Joseph (Alex) says that grapefruits are bullshit, to which Troy (Jay) responds that Alex is bullshit.
So if grapefruits are bullshit and Alex is bullshit we know that Alex is a grapefruit. Then we see that the grapefruit was actually Tim the entire time. So if Tim is a grapefruit and Alex is a grapefruit then Tim is Alex. However throughout the Marble Hornets series we see that Tim is Masky. So if Tim is Alex, and Tim is Masky, then it would be safe to conclude that Alex is actually Masky.

It breaks down like this:

Grapefruits=bullshit
Alex=bullshit
Alex=grapefruit
Tim=grapefruit
Alex=Tim
Tim=Masky
Alex=Masky

It makes sense now. Alex is Masky through the entire series. Tim is just an imaginary friend that Jay and Alex made up, same goes for slenderman.

I think in due time you will all come to respect and accept this theory.

[Rodion Romanovich]

[device]

[Jamocha101]

[Ithilwen22]

[Zarggg]

OK... Let's cool it with the off-topic/joke speculations for a while.

[Slendrdog]

So I've been rewatching the old entries (yay DVDs) and I just noticed how Alex tells J he doesn't want to be followed back to his apartment (#43 I think?) and this sort of got me thinking. Alex isn't thinking J himself will do something because if it was literally J he didn't want knowing where he lived, what would be the point? Even if he said 'I don't think it's a good idea for you to know where I live', if J really had cause to he could follow alex home using his super-sleuthing skills. Now sure, we all know J is sort of lacking in the stealth department but I doubt Alex would rely on that too too much...

My point is, what if Alex thinks that if J knows where he lives (assuming he doesn't film it) someone else will also have access to that information, possibly via having access to J's mind? Okay this is sounding way more out-there than I intended, but could this be evidence that either J has a masked persona which is why he's losing chunks of time, or that Alex thinks he is a masky.

Also this kind of just occurred to me as I was typing and I'm pretty sure its a WMG but what if Alex is going after the TTA group by luring them in in their more vulnerable state (when they're not their masked personas) and that's what the entirety of season 2 was-Alex taking Tim out with the rock then going after J and Jessica to try and stop totheark from whatever it is totheark is trying to accomplish? Implying that J and Jessica are both tothearkians? Or that Alex has reason to believe they are?

I feel like I may have just talked myself in circles and accomplished nothing. Yaaaay for speculation!

[pravado]

[Slendrdog]

Ahh, okay, that makes sense, I guess I was just assuming that Alex would've counted Tim as dealt with/out of commission since this was after the rock smash but before the attack at his apartment.

But then again, it's obvious he was hiding something from J the whole time, so the J/masked-J persona isn't necessarily vital to explaining why Alex wouldn't want J knowing where his apartment was (the fact that J proved Alex right by breaking into his apartment later doesn't exactly help my case either, I guess).

[pravado]