unforum

[CraicIsMighty]

I could be wrong, but I was pretty sure one of the twisted up faces in Inquiry was supposed to be Seth. Too lazy to check though.

Anyway, we don't really have any hard IG evidence pointing towards ANYONE for Hoodie's identity, so while I don't see how Sarah is more likely than Seth or Brian, I don't see why Seth or Brian are more likely than Sarah either. Most of the evidence pointing towards Brian is OOG stuff, like the fact that he was at that event and that Trosephim have intentionally started having the characters mention him more. But IG the only thing we absolutely know about Hoodie is that it can't be Alex, Jay, or Tim. Any other character is fair game.

As for Jessica, well it's true that she wasn't involved in MH. However this season has made it pretty clear that Tim had troubles with Oppy long before becoming involved with MH. And Jessica is from the same town as Tim. So I don't see why not being involved with MH automatically knocks her out of the running.

[Zarggg]

Amy was Alex's girlfriend in 2009 and Jessica was her (Amy's) roommate.

They were not involved in the production of Marble Hornets.

[TheOperator]

I think it's Jessica. To summarise what I said in the Entry #33 thread, she's the only one who could have known to write down the combination to Jay's safe but it's drawn with an Operator symbol and Jay was not given it until he found it. She also had the chance to encounter the Operator since her roommate was attacked, so it's completely possible for it to be her.

I also think it's highly unlikely to be Sarah or Seth because casual viewers wouldn't even remember they existed. Hoody should at least be someone who's face was on the screen for more than 3 minutes.

[CraicIsMighty]

[Zarggg]

No, it was a response to McGregor and Debaser.

[Lithp]

>I know "we can't use builds as evidence," but I think there's a difference between using a person's specific build & pointing out that generally, Hoody's got a pretty masculine frame. I highly doubt they would do that if they wanted to later sell people on the idea that Hoody is a chick.

>Jessica was not necessarily the only person to have that knowledge, considering that Jay is constantly being spied on. Though it does seem weird that someone would leave him the combination rather than just opening the safe.

[CraicIsMighty]

[Lithp]

If you have counter-evidence, by all means, go ahead. But I don't see any female characteristics on Hoody. Furthermore, the only actors I'm aware of who are confirmed to have played him were male, & we know they have a problem getting a hold of female actors.

[TheOperator]

[Lithp]

Because it would be moronic? There's a big difference between determining which specific person it is, & determining whether it's probably a boy or a girl. Most people can do the latter without much real difficulty, especially since Hoody's the fucking Hulk in some entries.

Now, when Troy plays Hoody, sure, they could sell him as a chick. But when it's someone like Brian or Tim...yeah, no one's buying it.

[Xman]

Yeah, it's not good to base theories on the build of Hoody, considering Troy, Alex, Tim, and Brian have all played as him (I'm pretty sure).

I do think that we can almost safely say that Hoody is male though. I just feel like if a girl were to wear that outfit, they would look significantly different with the breasts and the hips and all.

I chose Brian for my vote. I sort of hope I'm wrong, but it'd be fine with me if it was him.

[matixzun]

I can't believe two have voted for Sarah, Looks like some people can't see the difference between male and female.

[CraicIsMighty]

[Lithp]

Your opinions are not legitimate counterarguments.

[TheOperator]

It may have been better to have Hoody wear baggier trousers to make his/her shape shifting a little more believable. Either way, the inconsistency isn't a big deal to me personally and I agree that just using another argument based on builds isn't very convincing. It's a fact that OOG elements are not supposed to be used to determine Hoody's identity and it's also a fact that female actors are hard to use on a regular basis for Trosephim. They just use who is most convenient, even if it means Hoody's build changing.