unforum

[Kraehtot]

Maybe I AM Hoody and I didn't notice because of my split personality. Maybe each night I travel to the States in an airplane to stalk Jay and to smile at Alex. And yeah, I've got the money to do that because of my split personality too. Also, I am a girl, but my split personality is a male. This would be AWESOME and unexpected xDDD

No, seriously, I am just exagerating that , but if we want, we can explain everythig with the argument of 'split personalities'. We could say the same for all the other characters except those who had been in Hoody's presence. There's only a thing that cannot be explained by split personality: Hoody seems to be in active way before Amy encountered the Operator being with Alex, so that thing of "Hoody is Jessica because TO attacked her room mate and she developed another personality to fight back" does not suit with the timeline. Maybe Jessica has been exposed to TO before, because of the things she described she saw in her dreams, but even if it is true, I don't see why she would have known about Jay and started stalking him and being in gang with Masky.

Edit: I must apologyze for my grammar mistakes T_T I don't have an "English mind" today.

[Lithp]

I expected the "split personality" defense, that's why I focused on timeline inconsistencies.

[The Condor]

Wow, we're really into this aren't we?

There is a slight chance that Hoody might be someone outside the crew that has yet to be introduced but that'd seem a little... off.

[Hazman]

[Kraehtot]

[Hazman]

[Malckeor]

Skyrim was a bad game.


Anyway, I'm not sure who Hoody could be. There's valid enough explanations for both Brian and Seth. It feels like Trosephim are making Brian a bit too obvious, though. I don't know.

I was in the lonely camp that Hoody could be Amy, but given Alex's reaction in the most recent entry, it's looking like I'm going to have to leave my cozy camp behind.

[sp103]

Well I've said it before-They are putting a LOT of effort to hide Hoody's identity including gloves and hood. Let's face it-we will able to identify TIM very easily, and since they use other actors to play Hoodie the screwjob could be in and hoody is a female character...Likely Sarah.

[Lithp]

Why do people keep bringing up gloves? Who the Hell uses the hands to identify a person's sex? Actually, let me turn that argument on its head: If they don't care that Hoody looks ubermasculine in some entries, why does he need gloves? We're not going to question how she shrinks down & suddenly grows a pair of breasts, why should it bother us that his hand size, hairiness, & knuckle shape change?

[The Condor]

[Hazman]

[Toadbert]

[The Condor]

[TheOperator]

A lot of this we'll have to agree to disagree on... well, partially agree in regards to Jessica being more involved than it seems. I'll respond where I feel there's still room for debate.

[Ixica]

I have to say I believe it's Brian. Here's why:

First, who is Brian to the rest of the cast? Brian was Tim's friend and Alex's friend (can't remember what entry it was mentioned in) and lived close to one of them (or both).

Second, who is Brian in the Marble Hornets student film? He's the lead actor, which means that he'd be around Alex the most. Now who are the ones haunted by the Operator? Alex (possibly since he was a kid but maybe not) and Tim (haunted since childhood).

So, here's my idea of what happened (lots of speculation and probably all of it BS):

Brian was asked by Alex to star in his student film and Brian dragged Tim along to help out.

I don't know who first had dealings with the Operator so maybe it was Alex's fault, maybe it was Tim's. Perhaps it was their meeting that sparked it. I, personally, blame Tim. I think Tim has had the Operator around him, pills or not, and Alex always had the Operator (enttry 37) but never noticed like Tim did: It's been shown that sometimes people don't see the Operator, even if he's in the same room. The Operator might have lost interest in Alex because Alex couldn't see him but I don't have any evidence for that except Alex didn't go crazy until later in life.

I think that the Operator was hanging around Tim and Alex caught him on film. He started seeing him everywhere and the Operator started paying more attention to Alex. Alex went nuts but Tim was fine as ever because he had his magic pills of normality. Brian, due to being around Alex or messing with the raw footage, begins noticing the Operator, too. He confesses to Tim that he's been seeing things and Tim gives him some of his pills that he takes for his hallucinations (Entry 16).

Brian notices Alex running around after or from the Operator or acting strange and starts making a connection. And becomes angry. Brian tells Tim that he thinks Alex is to blame but Tim confesses that he's been seeing the Operator, too, and might have been doing so since he was a kid. Brian comes up with a battle plan. They'd find a way to defeat the creature haunting them. He tries to talk to Alex but Alex is irrational and angry and won't listen.

Later, Alex attempts to give Brian and Tim to the Operator under the guise of filming Marble Hornets (Entry 51) but they get away. Alex later lies about what happened, claims he can't remember, or just shouts nonsense angrily until he and Brian have a falling out. Due to Brian and Tim no longer trusting him and refusing to work with him Alex cancels the Marble Hornets film.

Tim moves in with Brian so that they can take turns looking out for the Operator and watching Alex and they both stop taking the pills. They cover up their faces in an attempt to hide themselves from the Operator and to keep Alex from knowing who they are if he catches them.

Alex, tired, frustrated, and angry, decides to leave the town and be normal again. Jay gets the tapes and Alex is gone (Introduction).

Tim has a breakdown and starts taking the pills again and tries putting it all behind him. Brian keeps going, determined. He learns how to best avoid the Operator, stalks Alex a bit, and becomes very good at surviving, all while trying to find a way stop the Operator. Years later, Brian notices something on Youtube. He starts helping Jay in as subtle a way as possible because he's cautious and wary of Alex's involvement and actions.

I have more of this scenario that deals with TimMasky's involvement, Hoody's doings, TTA, the pills, the ark, Brian's house, Brian's missing status, the bullet casing, and Tim's memory issues but I don't really care to post it all and make this longer than it has to be when someone with better knowledge will correct me soon anyway. Or they'll ask me for evidence of which I have none.

Hoody could also be Seth but I think Brian makes more sense.